–no score
Our verdict
Not enough data
- More complaints than 5% of 2005 vehicles
- Most reported problem: electrical system (50% of complaints)
- 1 safety recall
- 1 fire reported
How we score
Most reported 2005 GMC Yukon XL 2500 problems
Owner complaints filed with NHTSA, grouped by problem area. One complaint can mention several areas.
Transmission & powertrain2 (50%)
When owners reported problems
Complaints by the year they were filed.
Recent owner complaints
Jun 8, 2015electrical system, structure, wheels
While driving on an interstate highway at 70 MPH I experience a total tire failure whereas the middle 4 inches of the tread/belt area of my bf goodrich lt245/75 r 16 lre m+s commercial t/a all season bf11 jd11 4011 tire completely separated from the tire's core, resulting in the remainder of the tire's tread/belt to continue stripping away causing significant wheel well, rear… Read more
While driving on an interstate highway at 70 MPH I experience a total tire failure whereas the middle 4 inches of the tread/belt area of my bf goodrich lt245/75 r 16 lre m+s commercial t/a all season bf11 jd11 4011 tire completely separated from the tire's core, resulting in the remainder of the tire's tread/belt to continue stripping away causing significant wheel well, rear quarter panel, gas tub, and electrical harness damage to my 2005 Yukon XL 2500. Tires had just passed a nc safety inspection, were properly inflated with 38,000 miles on them.
NHTSA complaint #10724122
Mar 31, 2010electrical systemFire
On march 13, 2010 at 7 am I found my 2005 GMC yukon xl, which was parked and locked in my driveway at the time, with the right rear turn signal flashing. After obtaining the keys to unlock the vehicle and upon opening the driver door I found the dash board completely melted as a result of a spontaneous fire which had occurred sometime after 12 am that morning. There was a… Read more
On march 13, 2010 at 7 am I found my 2005 GMC yukon xl, which was parked and locked in my driveway at the time, with the right rear turn signal flashing. After obtaining the keys to unlock the vehicle and upon opening the driver door I found the dash board completely melted as a result of a spontaneous fire which had occurred sometime after 12 am that morning. There was a small hole in the front windshield just above where the fire occurred. The headliner was completely charred all the way to the back of the vehicle. The contents of the vehicle were covered in heavy soot including a brand new toddler car seat, stroller, softball gear bag, DVD notebook filled with DVD's and various tools. After the fire was investigated by the maryland state fire marshall's office the fire was determined to be electrical. It never penetrated through the firewall into the engine compartment. It was also determined that the fire extinguished itself due to lack of oxygen and never affected the outside of the vehicle other than the hole left behind in the upper left hand corner of the windshield. It was raining that night, so it is believed the rain is what kept enough oxygen from entering through the hole. We contacted GM and our insurance immediately. We didn't hear back from GM until 3 days after the occurrence. They took a report. We were told that "the report would be sent to texas and we should hear something back within 5-10 business days." today is day 11 and the only thing
NHTSA complaint #10322994
Dec 9, 2009power train
The 4 wheel drive intermittently works on our 2005 GMC yukon xl, therefore you never know in bad whether, in a slippery situation, if its working. I understand that a sensor on these vehicles is failing. In fact the part is on back order, because so many are failing. This is a real safety problem. *tr
NHTSA complaint #10295109
Jul 4, 2007power train
While driving our 2005 Yukon XL 2500 series vehicle the service 4wd message will alert from time to time at which point the ability to continue in 2wd is not affected but the ability to transfer into 4wd hi or lo is eliminated. Turning the car off then back on clears the error and systems are again operable. This was fixed before under warranty but the problem still occurs… Read more
While driving our 2005 Yukon XL 2500 series vehicle the service 4wd message will alert from time to time at which point the ability to continue in 2wd is not affected but the ability to transfer into 4wd hi or lo is eliminated. Turning the car off then back on clears the error and systems are again operable. This was fixed before under warranty but the problem still occurs without warning. Problem has occurred in excess of six times over the past two years since purchasing the vehicle new.
NHTSA complaint #10195319
2005 GMC Yukon XL 2500 recalls (1)
Certain replacement fuel filters, fram brand name p/n g3727, with date codes x52911 through x60801 sequentially or x600141 and a mexico country or origin marking on the fuel filter housing manufactured from october 18, 2005, through march 21, 2006, sold for use on the vehicles listed above and on certain school buses. (to see the school bus engine sizes, click on "document search" and then "bus applications"). The connector on the fuel filter was not manufactured to honeywell's specification. As a result, the o-ring may not seat correctly on the fuel line.
Risk: This condition may cause an inadequate seal at the connection, potentially leading to a fuel leak. In the presence of an ignition source, a fire could occur.
Remedy: Honeywell will notify owners and replace the fuel filters free of charge. The recall began on october 18, 2006. Owners may contact fram customer service at 1-800-890-2075 (option 1).
Other GMC Yukon XL 2500 years
Frequently asked questions
Is the 2005 GMC Yukon XL 2500 a reliable car?
There is not enough complaint data to score the 2005 GMC Yukon XL 2500 yet.
What are the most common problems with the 2005 GMC Yukon XL 2500?
Owners most often report problems with electrical system (2 complaints), transmission & powertrain (2 complaints), body & structure (1 complaints).
How many recalls does the 2005 GMC Yukon XL 2500 have?
1 recall is on file with NHTSA, including: 06E043000 (fuel system, gasoline).
Source: NHTSA complaints & recalls, EPA fueleconomy.gov. Data updated November 18, 2026. Complaints are unverified reports by owners.