How we score cars
Every model year with enough data gets a score from 1 (worst) to 10 (best) and a verdict: Good choice (7.5+), Average (5.5–7.4), Buy with caution (3.5–5.4) or Avoid this year (below 3.5).
What goes into the score
- Complaints compared with other vehicles of the same model year (the biggest factor). Comparing cars of the same age is fair, because older cars have had more time to collect complaints.
- Complaints compared with other years of the same model — a year with far more complaints than its siblings is usually a problem year.
- Number of safety recalls.
- Share of serious complaints involving a crash, fire or injury.
Limitations
Complaint counts are not adjusted for sales volume, so very popular models naturally collect more complaints. Complaints are unverified reports filed by owners; a complaint does not prove a defect. Use the score as a starting point and always get a pre-purchase inspection and check the vehicle's VIN for open recalls.
Model years with fewer than 5 complaints and fewer than 2 recalls are shown without a score.