CarProblemsDB

2005 Subaru Forester problems, recalls & MPG

NHTSA has received 93 complaints from owners of the 2005 Subaru Forester, most often about the fuel & propulsion system. There is 1 safety recall for this model year. The EPA rates it at about 21 MPG combined.

5.6out of 10
Our verdict
Average
  • More complaints than 58% of 2005 vehicles
  • Most reported problem: fuel & propulsion system (24% of complaints)
  • 1 safety recall
  • 15 crashes, 1 fire, 11 injuries reported
How we score
Complaints93
Recalls1
MPG combined21
Safety—

Most reported 2005 Subaru Forester problems

Owner complaints filed with NHTSA, grouped by problem area. One complaint can mention several areas.

Suspension21 (23%)
Brakes7 (8%)
Airbags5 (5%)
Transmission & powertrain5 (5%)
Body & structure4 (4%)
Electrical system3 (3%)
Other / unknown3 (3%)
Visibility, windows & wipers3 (3%)
Steering2 (2%)
Wheels2 (2%)
Equipment1 (1%)

When owners reported problems

92005
32006
12007
12008
72009
92010
22011
32012
82013
82014
102015
42016
102017
32018
32019
52020
12021
22022
42023

Complaints by the year they were filed.

Recent owner complaints

May 4, 2023suspension
The contact owns a 2005 Subaru Forester. The contact stated while driving 55 MPH, the vehicle failed to respond to the steering wheel turning. The contact stated that upon depressing the brake pedal, the vehicle decelerated but the front passenger's side of the vehicle was sliding. The contact was able to veer to the side of the road. The vehicle was towed to an independent… Read more

The contact owns a 2005 Subaru Forester. The contact stated while driving 55 MPH, the vehicle failed to respond to the steering wheel turning. The contact stated that upon depressing the brake pedal, the vehicle decelerated but the front passenger's side of the vehicle was sliding. The contact was able to veer to the side of the road. The vehicle was towed to an independent mechanic, where it was diagnosed that the front passenger's side control arm had fractured, and the axle was damaged. The dealer was not notified of the failure. The vehicle was not repaired. The contact stated that the vehicle was previously repaired under NHTSA campaign number: 11v464000 (suspension), which he related to the failure. The manufacturer was notified of the failure and informed the contact that they could assist because of the age of the vehicle. The failure mileage was approximately 175,000.

NHTSA complaint #11520398
Mar 28, 2023air bags, vehicle speed control, fuel/propulsion systemCrash1 injured
Moved car 30’ from gas pumps to air pump. Slowed to almost complete stop to move closer to air tank. Car accelerated at extremely high speed over curb, knocking over air pump. Car proceeded to smash through landscaping shrubs and hit a tree and nearby pole which stopped the car dead. Felt like a fighter plane pushed me. Entire incident probably lasted a minute. Air bags failed… Read more

Moved car 30’ from gas pumps to air pump. Slowed to almost complete stop to move closer to air tank. Car accelerated at extremely high speed over curb, knocking over air pump. Car proceeded to smash through landscaping shrubs and hit a tree and nearby pole which stopped the car dead. Felt like a fighter plane pushed me. Entire incident probably lasted a minute. Air bags failed to deploy. Car was totaled. I suffered severe facial and othet bruising and have ongoing fatigue and am eadily winded.

NHTSA complaint #11514233
Mar 22, 2023power train

The contact owns a 2005 Subaru Forester. The contact stated while starting the vehicle, the vehicle accelerated unintendedly. There was no warning light illuminated. An unknown dealer and the manufacturer were notified of the failure and informed the contact that the vehicle needed to be diagnosed. The vehicle was not diagnosed nor repaired. The failure mileage was 183,000.

NHTSA complaint #11513189
Feb 7, 2023unknown or other
A part of the front frame was recalled because of rusting and was breaking on 3-20-12 they put a rust proof on the part knowing it would only last a few years instead of replacing the parts. The part is broken and they say the recall was complete but really they only put a bandaid on a serous problem knowing it wouldn’t last . They said they don’t have to replace and fix the… Read more

A part of the front frame was recalled because of rusting and was breaking on 3-20-12 they put a rust proof on the part knowing it would only last a few years instead of replacing the parts. The part is broken and they say the recall was complete but really they only put a bandaid on a serous problem knowing it wouldn’t last . They said they don’t have to replace and fix the damage caused to my car Subaru gave me a case number 230206-1400191

NHTSA complaint #11505995
Oct 13, 2022suspension
The contact owns a 2005 Subaru Forester. The contact stated that while driving from a complete stop at approximately 25 MPH, the front passenger's side subframe emitted an abnormally loud sound, and the front passenger's side tire detached from the vehicle. There was no warning light illuminated. The contact was able to veer to the side of the road where he noticed that the… Read more

The contact owns a 2005 Subaru Forester. The contact stated that while driving from a complete stop at approximately 25 MPH, the front passenger's side subframe emitted an abnormally loud sound, and the front passenger's side tire detached from the vehicle. There was no warning light illuminated. The contact was able to veer to the side of the road where he noticed that the front passenger's side lower control arm was fractured. The vehicle was towed to the contact's residence. The vehicle was then towed to the local dealer where it remained. The vehicle was not diagnosed or repaired. The manufacturer was made aware of the failure. The approximate failure mileage was 210,000.

NHTSA complaint #11489132
Mar 7, 2022fuel/propulsion system

Raw fuel smell inside cabin of card when cold outside

NHTSA complaint #11455530
Jul 17, 2021suspensionCrash
I was driving down the highway when my front drivers side control arm broke causing me to completely lose control of my vehicle. I was thrown down an embankment and into a cornfield where my vehicle came to a stop. I narrowly missed a telephone pole and culvert. I am extremely fortunate that my car went into a field rather than into oncoming traffic as this happened during… Read more

I was driving down the highway when my front drivers side control arm broke causing me to completely lose control of my vehicle. I was thrown down an embankment and into a cornfield where my vehicle came to a stop. I narrowly missed a telephone pole and culvert. I am extremely fortunate that my car went into a field rather than into oncoming traffic as this happened during rush hour traffic on a thursday night around 5-530pm. I’m glad that I was able to walk away from this and wasn’t killed. I had no warning lights, no laxity in steering, no warning at all-absolutely nothing that would’ve allowed me time to avoid this. The part failure has been recalled previously, and when I called Subaru I was told that the recall had been “taken care of” which concerns me that this part was “fixed” and still put my life in danger. Police were called to the scene and a report was written. My car was towed to a local shop to be evaluated and was considered a total loss due to the extent of the damage. I am still waiting to hear back from Subaru if there is anything they are willing or wanting to do. I don’t want this to happen to anyone else. I take amazing care of my vehicles, and haven’t even owned this car for a year. Now I am stuck in a completely unfair situation and having to carry the financial burden for something I was not responsible for. The vehicle is still available to be looked at as well, and I am more than happy to have someone look at the damage. I don’t want anyone to lose

NHTSA complaint #11425268
Nov 13, 2020engine, fuel/propulsion system

I've experienced the leaking fuel line when temperatures dropped below 20 degrees and get terrible gas fumes inside the cabin especially during cold and damp weather. It is more prominent with the heat on. This smell/leak can be noticed while parked, driving, anytime with the engine running with fuel pressure.

NHTSA complaint #11374591

2005 Subaru Forester recalls (1)

Recall 11V4640002011Suspension:front:control arm:lower arm

Subaru is recalling certain model year 2002-2007 impreza, model year 2003-2008 Forester, and model year 2005-2006 saab 9-2x vehicles manufactured from september 5, 2000 through november 26, 2007 originally sold, or currently registered in, massachusetts, maryland, michigan, new hampshire, new york, pennsylvania, vermont, wisconsin, connecticut, delaware, iowa, illinois, indiana, maine, minnesota, missouri, new jersey, ohio, rhode island, west virginia and the district of columbia. The front lower control arms may break at the hanger brackets due to corrosion if the hanger bracket is exposed to salty and humid environments such as roads containing snow melting agent.

Risk: A broken control arm can result in the loss of control of the vehicle, increasing the risk of a crash.

Remedy: Subaru will handle their vehicles and saab will handle theirs. Dealers will inspect the degree of corrosion of the front lower control arms, and will either rustproof or replace them. This service will be performed free of charge. The safety recall is expected to begin during december 2011. Owners may contact subaru at 1-800-782-2783. Owners may contact saab at 1-800-955-9007.

Fuel economy (EPA)

EngineTransmissionDriveCityHwyComb.
2.5L 4-cylManual 5-spd4-Wheel or All-Wheel Drive202723
2.5L 4-cylAutomatic 4-spd4-Wheel or All-Wheel Drive202622
2.5L 4-cylAutomatic 4-spd4-Wheel or All-Wheel Drive182219
2.5L 4-cylManual 5-spd4-Wheel or All-Wheel Drive172219

Crash-test ratings (NHTSA)

VersionOverallFrontalSideRollover
2005 Subaru Forester 4-DR. w/SAB———★★★★★

Other Subaru Forester years

Frequently asked questions

Is the 2005 Subaru Forester a reliable car?

Our score for the 2005 Subaru Forester is 5.6/10 (average). It is based on 93 owner complaints and 1 recall compared with other 2005 vehicles and other Subaru Forester years.

What are the most common problems with the 2005 Subaru Forester?

Owners most often report problems with fuel & propulsion system (22 complaints), suspension (21 complaints), speed control (cruise, throttle) (17 complaints).

How many recalls does the 2005 Subaru Forester have?

1 recall is on file with NHTSA, including: 11V464000 (suspension:front:control arm:lower arm).

What gas mileage does the 2005 Subaru Forester get?

The EPA rates the 2005 Subaru Forester at about 19 MPG city, 24 MPG highway and 21 MPG combined, depending on engine and drivetrain.

Source: NHTSA complaints & recalls, EPA fueleconomy.gov. Data updated November 18, 2026. Complaints are unverified reports by owners.