CarProblemsDB

2004 Subaru Forester problems, recalls & MPG

NHTSA has received 219 complaints from owners of the 2004 Subaru Forester, most often about the fuel & propulsion system. There are 2 safety recalls for this model year. The EPA rates it at about 20 MPG combined.

4.8out of 10
Our verdict
Buy with caution
  • More complaints than 79% of 2004 vehicles
  • Most reported problem: fuel & propulsion system (57% of complaints)
  • 2 safety recalls
  • 13 crashes, 4 fires, 8 injuries reported
How we score
Complaints219
Recalls2
MPG combined20
Safety—

Most reported 2004 Subaru Forester problems

Owner complaints filed with NHTSA, grouped by problem area. One complaint can mention several areas.

Suspension25 (11%)
Airbags21 (10%)
Other / unknown9 (4%)
Brakes5 (2%)
Body & structure4 (2%)
Electrical system4 (2%)
Wheels3 (1%)
Tires2 (1%)
Doors, latches & locks1 (0%)
Equipment1 (0%)
Seat belts1 (0%)
Seats1 (0%)
Steering1 (0%)
Visibility, windows & wipers1 (0%)

When owners reported problems

52004
92005
22006
62007
52008
92009
242010
212011
112012
172013
402014
162015
162016
92017
142018
42019
32020
42021
22022
12023
12024

Complaints by the year they were filed.

Recent owner complaints

Mar 28, 2024fuel/propulsion system

Leaking fuel lines under turbo in engine compartment when in cold weather

NHTSA complaint #11580020
Jan 30, 2023structure, service brakes, hydraulic
The contact owns a 2004 Subaru Forester. The contact stated that while driving an undisclosed speed, the brake pedal was depressed and extended to the floor, causing the braking distance to be extended. The vehicle was towed to the local dealer who discovered that the brake hoses had failed due to rusting and corrosion of the brake lines. The contact was also informed that the… Read more

The contact owns a 2004 Subaru Forester. The contact stated that while driving an undisclosed speed, the brake pedal was depressed and extended to the floor, causing the braking distance to be extended. The vehicle was towed to the local dealer who discovered that the brake hoses had failed due to rusting and corrosion of the brake lines. The contact was also informed that the entire subframe had sustained extensive rust and corrosion damage. The vehicle was not repaired. The failure mileage was 28,000.

NHTSA complaint #11504474
May 2, 2022suspension, service brakesCrash
My vehicle had a recall on the lower control arms that would rust and and break. That is exactly what happened while I was driving with my family. Control arm broke causing other parts to get destroyed. The fender breaks and other parts. The recall was performed before hand but it obviously wasn’t repaired correctly because it caused me to crash. Dave wright auto Subaru… Read more

My vehicle had a recall on the lower control arms that would rust and and break. That is exactly what happened while I was driving with my family. Control arm broke causing other parts to get destroyed. The fender breaks and other parts. The recall was performed before hand but it obviously wasn’t repaired correctly because it caused me to crash. Dave wright auto Subaru retailer in iowa is refusing to repair my failed recall attempt. Consumer stated failed repair caused the consumer to crash and damaged more of my vehicle.

NHTSA complaint #11463133
Mar 14, 2022suspension, unknown or other, engine

Bracket to the sway bar bushing fell off

NHTSA complaint #11456686
May 24, 2021suspension
The contact owns a 2004 Subaru Forester. The contact stated that while having a routine safety check performed on the vehicle, she learned that the lower control was completely rusted. The contact learned that the repair was covered under a special coverage. The contact stated that because the vehicle was not registered in a stated listed for the special coverage, the vehicle… Read more

The contact owns a 2004 Subaru Forester. The contact stated that while having a routine safety check performed on the vehicle, she learned that the lower control was completely rusted. The contact learned that the repair was covered under a special coverage. The contact stated that because the vehicle was not registered in a stated listed for the special coverage, the vehicle was not eligible for the free repair. The manufacturer was made aware of the issue and opened a case. The manufacturer confirmed that the vehicle was not included in NHTSA campaign number: 11v464000 (suspension). The vehicle was not repaired. The approximate failure mileage was 145,000.

NHTSA complaint #11418334
Apr 6, 2021fuel/propulsion system
There is a fuel leak on the low and high pressure fuel rubber hoses, and they cause fuel odor to enter the cb via climate control. It is a very strong odor, that requires me to either drive with the windows down or wait for the car to clear out the fuel odor out of the cabin. Mostly occurs during cold weather days. Once engine warms up, odor fades away. Many people with… Read more

There is a fuel leak on the low and high pressure fuel rubber hoses, and they cause fuel odor to enter the cb via climate control. It is a very strong odor, that requires me to either drive with the windows down or wait for the car to clear out the fuel odor out of the cabin. Mostly occurs during cold weather days. Once engine warms up, odor fades away. Many people with similar cars say is a common issue with subarus.

NHTSA complaint #11406648
Feb 1, 2021fuel/propulsion system

Neopreen hose to the right side fuel rail started leaking. This hose is near the top of the engine and the leak caused fuel to run all over engine, which was then drawn into the cabin via the climate control system. This occurred while driving, and raw fuel was dripping from the high pressure hose once stopped.

NHTSA complaint #11391059
Jan 12, 2021engine
Tl* the contact owns a 2004 Subaru Forester. The contact stated that there was a leak in the head gasket. The vehicle was taken to the local dealer herb gordon Subaru (3161 automobile blvd, silver spring, md 20904, (866) 520-7894) where it was diagnosed with the head cover gasket with needing to be replaced. The vehicle was not repaired. Upon investigation, the contact… Read more

Tl* the contact owns a 2004 Subaru Forester. The contact stated that there was a leak in the head gasket. The vehicle was taken to the local dealer herb gordon Subaru (3161 automobile blvd, silver spring, md 20904, (866) 520-7894) where it was diagnosed with the head cover gasket with needing to be replaced. The vehicle was not repaired. Upon investigation, the contact associated the failure with NHTSA campaign number: 04v473000 (engine and engine cooling) however, the VIN was not included. The manufacturer was informed of the failure. The contact was informed that the repairs were not covered under warranty and the costs for the repair would be out of pocket. The failure mileage was approximately 161,000.

NHTSA complaint #11387683

2004 Subaru Forester recalls (2)

Recall 11V4640002011Suspension:front:control arm:lower arm

Subaru is recalling certain model year 2002-2007 impreza, model year 2003-2008 Forester, and model year 2005-2006 saab 9-2x vehicles manufactured from september 5, 2000 through november 26, 2007 originally sold, or currently registered in, massachusetts, maryland, michigan, new hampshire, new york, pennsylvania, vermont, wisconsin, connecticut, delaware, iowa, illinois, indiana, maine, minnesota, missouri, new jersey, ohio, rhode island, west virginia and the district of columbia. The front lower control arms may break at the hanger brackets due to corrosion if the hanger bracket is exposed to salty and humid environments such as roads containing snow melting agent.

Risk: A broken control arm can result in the loss of control of the vehicle, increasing the risk of a crash.

Remedy: Subaru will handle their vehicles and saab will handle theirs. Dealers will inspect the degree of corrosion of the front lower control arms, and will either rustproof or replace them. This service will be performed free of charge. The safety recall is expected to begin during december 2011. Owners may contact subaru at 1-800-782-2783. Owners may contact saab at 1-800-955-9007.

Recall 04V4730002004Engine and engine cooling

On certain passenger and sport utility vehicles, the cover bolts for the engine oil control valve may not be sufficiently tightened, allowing oil to leak from around the cover gasket.

Risk: If leaking oil contacts components operating at high temperatures, a fire could result in the engine compartment.

Remedy: Dealers will inspect and retighten the oil-flow control valve cover bolts. The recall began on october 8, 2004. Owners should contact subaru at 1-800-782-2783.

Fuel economy (EPA)

EngineTransmissionDriveCityHwyComb.
2.5L 4-cylAutomatic 4-spd4-Wheel or All-Wheel Drive192521
2.5L 4-cylManual 5-spd4-Wheel or All-Wheel Drive192521
2.5L 4-cylAutomatic 4-spd4-Wheel or All-Wheel Drive172119
2.5L 4-cylManual 5-spd4-Wheel or All-Wheel Drive162218

Crash-test ratings (NHTSA)

VersionOverallFrontalSideRollover
2004 Subaru Forester 4-DR.w/SAB———★★★★★

Other Subaru Forester years

Frequently asked questions

Is the 2004 Subaru Forester a reliable car?

Our score for the 2004 Subaru Forester is 4.8/10 (buy with caution). It is based on 219 owner complaints and 2 recalls compared with other 2004 vehicles and other Subaru Forester years.

What are the most common problems with the 2004 Subaru Forester?

Owners most often report problems with fuel & propulsion system (124 complaints), engine & cooling (39 complaints), suspension (25 complaints).

How many recalls does the 2004 Subaru Forester have?

2 recalls are on file with NHTSA, including: 11V464000 (suspension:front:control arm:lower arm); 04V473000 (engine and engine cooling).

What gas mileage does the 2004 Subaru Forester get?

The EPA rates the 2004 Subaru Forester at about 18 MPG city, 24 MPG highway and 20 MPG combined, depending on engine and drivetrain.

Source: NHTSA complaints & recalls, EPA fueleconomy.gov. Data updated November 18, 2026. Complaints are unverified reports by owners.