CarProblemsDB

2010 BMW 535I problems, recalls & MPG

NHTSA has received 58 complaints from owners of the 2010 BMW 535I, most often about the fuel & propulsion system. There is 1 safety recall for this model year. The EPA rates it at about 20 MPG combined.

6out of 10
Our verdict
Average
  • More complaints than 62% of 2010 vehicles
  • Most reported problem: fuel & propulsion system (59% of complaints)
  • 1 safety recall
  • 3 crashes, 3 fires, 2 injuries reported
How we score
Complaints58
Recalls1
MPG combined20
Safety—

Most reported 2010 BMW 535I problems

Owner complaints filed with NHTSA, grouped by problem area. One complaint can mention several areas.

Electrical system7 (12%)
Airbags5 (9%)
Seat belts3 (5%)
Equipment2 (3%)
Exterior lighting2 (3%)
Transmission & powertrain2 (3%)
Visibility, windows & wipers2 (3%)
Body & structure1 (2%)
Brakes1 (2%)
Child Seat1 (2%)
Other / unknown1 (2%)
Seats1 (2%)
Speed control (cruise, throttle)1 (2%)
Stability control1 (2%)
Steering1 (2%)
Suspension1 (2%)
Tires1 (2%)

When owners reported problems

162010
12011
42012
32013
52014
52016
32017
22018
72019
82020
22021
12022
12025

Complaints by the year they were filed.

Recent owner complaints

Feb 28, 2025fuel/propulsion system

Consistent fuel pump error code 2aaf

NHTSA complaint #11645545
Jun 15, 2022electrical system, fuel/propulsion systemCrash
I was told by BMW that the high pressure fuel pump for these vehicles are under warranty for 100,000 miles or 10 years. I just purchased the vehicle to not only drive from new jersey to new york and shut down. Since then it caused an accident and the used dealer is just ignoring everything. I was also told there’s an electric water pump class action suit and also something… Read more

I was told by BMW that the high pressure fuel pump for these vehicles are under warranty for 100,000 miles or 10 years. I just purchased the vehicle to not only drive from new jersey to new york and shut down. Since then it caused an accident and the used dealer is just ignoring everything. I was also told there’s an electric water pump class action suit and also something with the trunk leaking. Now I do know that a vehicle is not supposed to be sold without recalls being stated and fixed. I’m already paid 10k for the car and then 1k for a starter . The vehicle is in the body shop having body repair due to the engine shutting down. If the engine shuts down it displays fuel pump malfunction and within 20-30 mins will start again. The BMW 535I has 96,000 miles on it and I don’t think it’s fair that I should be penalized for someone not following thru with repairs let alone having an accident on my insurance now. I’m asking please just help get the vehicle running again and all future service will absolutely be done through BMW. That’s how I handled my mercedes’ and plan so with this vehicle. I’m a single father that just took a severe beating financially and had to sell the mercedes’ and thought buying a BMW was a good choice being I had a similar issue with mercedes’ and they honored the repair due to the amount of time owned and still being in the mileage range of the defective part. Please help . Email-[xxx] cell- [xxx] [xxx] thank you in advance information redacted pursu

NHTSA complaint #11469497
Apr 26, 2021fuel system, gasoline, engine
Tl* the contact owns a 2010 BMW 535I. The contact stated while driving approximately 20-25 MPH, the vehicle loss motive power. The contact coasted and manually steered the vehicle to the side of the roadway. The contact stated that the fuel pump warning light was illuminated. The contact had the vehicle towed to rallye BMW (1 brush hollow rd, westbury, ny 11590, (516)… Read more

Tl* the contact owns a 2010 BMW 535I. The contact stated while driving approximately 20-25 MPH, the vehicle loss motive power. The contact coasted and manually steered the vehicle to the side of the roadway. The contact stated that the fuel pump warning light was illuminated. The contact had the vehicle towed to rallye BMW (1 brush hollow rd, westbury, ny 11590, (516) 226-7947) who had replaced an unknown part however, approximately a week later the failure recurred with the same warning light illuminated. The contact returned the vehicle to the same dealer and the fuel pump was replaced. The manufacturer was not made aware of the failure. The approximate failure mileage was 120,000.

NHTSA complaint #11413933
Jan 7, 2021fuel/propulsion system
Several times I was placed in peril while traveling at high rates of speed then the car stalls on us highway 95. There were also times when the car stalled while driving less than 35mph. When this happens I have no real control to steer the wheel, no prior warning or issues with the car to indicate it would stall. It is extremely traumatizing. Traumatizing! Message of "fuel… Read more

Several times I was placed in peril while traveling at high rates of speed then the car stalls on us highway 95. There were also times when the car stalled while driving less than 35mph. When this happens I have no real control to steer the wheel, no prior warning or issues with the car to indicate it would stall. It is extremely traumatizing. Traumatizing! Message of "fuel pump malfunction. Moderate driving possible". Car stalls while in motion whether it is 20mph or 65mph. Initial malfunction in july was after 1hr of driving then several times after that periodically as the car isn't driven often due to stay at home restrictions. The issue could not be duplicated at two auto mechanic shops, in fact by the time the tow truck arrived, the car started and was able to be driven onto the truck. There is no pattern of driving behavior or messages between failure / stall and as months went on, the time between stall and inability to start the car shortened from driving1hr to driving 10 minutes. BMW of the main line replaced the fuel pump, fuel filter and stall and error issue remains. Wiring to fuel pump issue possible. There are several open complaints on the exact same issue. Model year 2010 should be included in the recall for 535I xdrive https://www.NHTSA.gov/vehicle/2010/BMW/5%252520 series/4%252520dr/rwd%25252f4wd#complaints https://www.NHTSA.gov/vehicle/2010/BMW/5%252520series/4%252520dr/rwd%25252f4wd#complaints wiring issue detected and may be part of the recall nhts

NHTSA complaint #11387031
Nov 23, 2020fuel/propulsion system

Receiving p0087 low pressure fuel, car goes into drivetrain malfunction. Fix is replacing high pressure fuel pump.

NHTSA complaint #11375976
Jul 2, 2020fuel/propulsion system

When staring up, extended crank/slow startup . Contacted BMW 'fuel pump issue'. Not covered on current recalls because of year of car. All other 5 series have an open recall for the same problem

NHTSA complaint #11337262
Jul 2, 2020engine and engine cooling, electrical system
Tl* the contact owns a 2010 BMW 535I. The contact stated that while driving 40 MPH, the battery discharging message displayed on the instrument panel. The vehicle stalled. The vehicle was towed to independent mechanic to be diagnosed. The contact was informed that the drive belts, battery, intelligent battery sensor (ibs) system, bolts, hose and engine cooling system needed to… Read more

Tl* the contact owns a 2010 BMW 535I. The contact stated that while driving 40 MPH, the battery discharging message displayed on the instrument panel. The vehicle stalled. The vehicle was towed to independent mechanic to be diagnosed. The contact was informed that the drive belts, battery, intelligent battery sensor (ibs) system, bolts, hose and engine cooling system needed to be replaced. The contact referenced the failure to NHTSA campaign number: 14v176000 (engine and engine cooling) however, the VIN was not included. An unknown dealer was contacted and informed of the failure but provided no additional assistance. The vehicle was not repaired. The manufacturer was informed of failure. The failure mileage was approximately 70,000.*dt

NHTSA complaint #11337163
Jun 27, 2020suspension, engine
I had the car serviced by a mechanic because I had check engine light faults. Water pump and thermostat was replaced. Spark plugs and cops were replaced. Some of the fuel injectors were also replaced. Mechanic asked me to drive the car for 100 miles to see if any check engine issues will reappear. The vehicle first began stating it had low oil pressure and would not allow… Read more

I had the car serviced by a mechanic because I had check engine light faults. Water pump and thermostat was replaced. Spark plugs and cops were replaced. Some of the fuel injectors were also replaced. Mechanic asked me to drive the car for 100 miles to see if any check engine issues will reappear. The vehicle first began stating it had low oil pressure and would not allow me to check the oil level, it would continue to just stop at 15%. I then restarted the vehicle and the indicator went away for the low oil pressure. I drove about 10 more miles and drive train malfunction appeared and I pulled over immediately. The vehicle was towed to the mechanic. Engine was seized. What was found in the engine was "shards of metal". Many people had the same issue with the 5 series BMW engines. I think that BMW is responsible for these engine failures. *tr

NHTSA complaint #11331245

2010 BMW 535I recalls (1)

Recall 13V4070002013Exterior lighting:tail lights

BMW is recalling certain model year 2008 through 2010 528i, 535I, 550i, and m5 passenger cars manufactured from march 1, 2007, through december 31, 2009. Over time, increased resistance at the taillight electrical contact points may cause damage to the ground terminal and housing of the connector resulting in an intermittent or permanent loss of functionality of one or more rear lamp functions (tail, brake, turn-signal, reverse).

Risk: Intermittent light operation reduces the ability to warn other motorists of the driver's intentions, increasing the risk of a crash.

Remedy: Bmw will notify owners, and dealers will replace the rear lamp bulb carriers free of charge. Owners may contact bmw customer relations at 1-800-525-7417 or email bmw at [email protected].

Fuel economy (EPA)

EngineTransmissionDriveCityHwyComb.
3.0L 6-cylAutomatic (S6)Rear-Wheel Drive172620
3.0L 6-cylManual 6-spdRear-Wheel Drive172620
3.0L 6-cylAutomatic (S6)All-Wheel Drive172520
3.0L 6-cylManual 6-spdAll-Wheel Drive162519

Other BMW 535I years

Frequently asked questions

Is the 2010 BMW 535I a reliable car?

Our score for the 2010 BMW 535I is 6/10 (average). It is based on 58 owner complaints and 1 recall compared with other 2010 vehicles and other BMW 535I years.

What are the most common problems with the 2010 BMW 535I?

Owners most often report problems with fuel & propulsion system (34 complaints), engine & cooling (16 complaints), electrical system (7 complaints).

How many recalls does the 2010 BMW 535I have?

1 recall is on file with NHTSA, including: 13V407000 (exterior lighting:tail lights).

What gas mileage does the 2010 BMW 535I get?

The EPA rates the 2010 BMW 535I at about 17 MPG city, 26 MPG highway and 20 MPG combined, depending on engine and drivetrain.

Source: NHTSA complaints & recalls, EPA fueleconomy.gov. Data updated November 18, 2026. Complaints are unverified reports by owners.