Odometer fraud. The contact owns a 2009 BMW 535I. The contact researched and discovered that there was a mileage discrepancy. The vehicle was a private sale. At the time of purchase, the mileage was 86,000, and it was later discovered via www.iaai.com that the mileage was 117,006 in may 2024 and 192,000 in february 2021.
2009 BMW 535I problems, recalls & MPG
NHTSA has received 72 complaints from owners of the 2009 BMW 535I, most often about the fuel & propulsion system. There is 1 safety recall for this model year. The EPA rates it at about 20 MPG combined.
- More complaints than 67% of 2009 vehicles
- Most reported problem: fuel & propulsion system (58% of complaints)
- 1 safety recall
- 2 crashes, 2 fires, 1 injury reported
Most reported 2009 BMW 535I problems
Owner complaints filed with NHTSA, grouped by problem area. One complaint can mention several areas.
When owners reported problems
Complaints by the year they were filed.
Recent owner complaints
I believe using the manual shift mode for normal usage of optimal shifting in certain driving situations and gentle downshifting caused a malfunction in the functionality of the transmission that LED to a complete transmission failure. I don’t believe it’s a mechanical issue or result of misuse. There were no warning signs. Only that every time the manual shift option was… Read more
I believe using the manual shift mode for normal usage of optimal shifting in certain driving situations and gentle downshifting caused a malfunction in the functionality of the transmission that LED to a complete transmission failure. I don’t believe it’s a mechanical issue or result of misuse. There were no warning signs. Only that every time the manual shift option was used, it would cause an error to occur that caused an automatic shifting issue that would reset if the vehicle was shut down and restarted.
The contact owns a 2009 BMW 535I equipped with mastercraft tires, tire line: stratus, tire size: 225/50/r17. The contact stated while driving at undisclosed speeds, the passenger's side rear tire was bubbling, and the vehicle was unstable. The vehicle was pulled to the side of the road and the contact observed that the tread belt was broken. The tire was not the original… Read more
The contact owns a 2009 BMW 535I equipped with mastercraft tires, tire line: stratus, tire size: 225/50/r17. The contact stated while driving at undisclosed speeds, the passenger's side rear tire was bubbling, and the vehicle was unstable. The vehicle was pulled to the side of the road and the contact observed that the tread belt was broken. The tire was not the original equipment. The vehicle was taken to an independent mechanic where the rear tires were replaced. The tires were replaced with the same tire brand and tire line however, the failure recurred with the driver's side rear tire. The tire was replaced with the same tire brand and tire line. The contact discovered NHTSA campaign number: 19t024000 (tires), however, the dot number was not included. The manufacturer was not made aware of the failure. The vehicle failure mileage was 177,259. The tire failure mileage was unknown.
The contact owns a 2009 BMW 535I. The contact stated that while driving at an undisclosed speed, the vehicle vibrated violently with a message displayed to, "check engine – engine power reduced”. The check engine warning light was illuminated. The vehicle was taken to an independent mechanic, who diagnosed failures with the spark plugs and ignition coil. The vehicle was… Read more
The contact owns a 2009 BMW 535I. The contact stated that while driving at an undisclosed speed, the vehicle vibrated violently with a message displayed to, "check engine – engine power reduced”. The check engine warning light was illuminated. The vehicle was taken to an independent mechanic, who diagnosed failures with the spark plugs and ignition coil. The vehicle was repaired, but the failure reoccurred. The vehicle was taken back to the independent mechanic, who diagnosed failures with the valve cover gasket and upper radiator hose. The vehicle was repaired, but the failure reoccurred. The vehicle was taken back to the independent mechanic, who diagnosed failures with the evaporative leak detection assembly, water pump, and high-pressure fuel pump. The vehicle was repaired, but the failure reoccurred. The manufacturer was notified of the failure but did not assist. The failure mileage was 70,000.
While driving I have received engine malfunction and steering becomes hard and unsafe. Have had the engine belt shred to pieces and case major issues. Same repair has been completed multiple times. Great vehicle becoming unsafe to have on the road. What component or system failed or malfunctioned, and is it available for inspection upon request? Engine malfunction, battery… Read more
While driving I have received engine malfunction and steering becomes hard and unsafe. Have had the engine belt shred to pieces and case major issues. Same repair has been completed multiple times. Great vehicle becoming unsafe to have on the road. What component or system failed or malfunctioned, and is it available for inspection upon request? Engine malfunction, battery malfunction and yes. How was your safety or the safety of others put at risk? This put my safety at risk because I was on the expressway and the steering was hard to turn or direct. Has the problem been reproduced or confirmed by a dealer or independent service center? Yes were there any warning lamps, messages or other symptoms of the problem prior to the failure, and when did they first appear? No there were not any other messages or symptoms of the problem prior to the failure. When the light came on, I pulled over in a safe place. This has happened the first time on august 20, 2019; 2nd time november 9, 2019; 3rd time march 22, 2020; 4th time january 20, 2021; 5th time june 6, 2022. This is too costly for BMW certified parts to continue to occur. As reputable as the product is and with certified technicians, there should be a recall on the continuous leaks and belt shredding causing major issues to the vehicle. 17-22-2-245-358 - (2) o-ring 83-19-2-451-316 - BMW non-chlor. Brak 11-28-7-628-653 - ribbed v-belt. 11-42-7-573-212 - thermostat housing 11-42-8-637-820 - gasket 17-22-2-245-358 – (2) o-r
The contact owns a 2009 BMW 535I. The contact stated that upon taking the vehicle to an independent mechanic for servicing, he was informed that the vehicle was leaking oil. The oil filter housing and the valve cover gaskets were replaced. Additionally, the contact stated while driving at various speeds, the check engine warning light illuminated. The vehicle was taken to an… Read more
The contact owns a 2009 BMW 535I. The contact stated that upon taking the vehicle to an independent mechanic for servicing, he was informed that the vehicle was leaking oil. The oil filter housing and the valve cover gaskets were replaced. Additionally, the contact stated while driving at various speeds, the check engine warning light illuminated. The vehicle was taken to an independent mechanic where it was diagnosed that the spark plugs and the coil pack needed to be replaced. The contact stated that the vehicle was repaired; however, the failure persisted. The vehicle was taken back to an independent mechanic who diagnosed that the coil pack needed to be replaced. Additionally, the contact stated that the turn signals and the horn were no longer operatives. The independent mechanic diagnosed that the steering column had failed. The contact also stated that the rear passenger's side and the rear driver's side windows were no longer operating as needed. The vehicle was not repaired. The manufacturer was notified of the failure but provided no assistance. The failure mileage was approximately 115,600. The consumer stated there is a recall for this vehicle.
Passenger side safety restraint malfunction. Passenger airbag no longer enabled because seat occupancy sensor is faulty. Passenger is at risk as airbag no longer working. This problem was confirmed and diagnosed by an independent auto technician. BMW fault code 93c3 the vehicle has not been inspected by the manufacturer as BMW wants $2,500 to make the repair. Warning lights… Read more
Passenger side safety restraint malfunction. Passenger airbag no longer enabled because seat occupancy sensor is faulty. Passenger is at risk as airbag no longer working. This problem was confirmed and diagnosed by an independent auto technician. BMW fault code 93c3 the vehicle has not been inspected by the manufacturer as BMW wants $2,500 to make the repair. Warning lights on dash say passenger restraint system malfunction. Passenger airbag no longer enabled. Issues started occurring two weeks ago.
The car stop running completly when I was wainting at the stop light an anounsmemt came out in my dash saying that I have to repleaced the fuel pump I know that there was a recall abuot this problem but I never got any notice or letter from BMW
2009 BMW 535I recalls (1)
BMW is recalling certain model year 2008 through 2010 528i, 535I, 550i, and m5 passenger cars manufactured from march 1, 2007, through december 31, 2009. Over time, increased resistance at the taillight electrical contact points may cause damage to the ground terminal and housing of the connector resulting in an intermittent or permanent loss of functionality of one or more rear lamp functions (tail, brake, turn-signal, reverse).
Risk: Intermittent light operation reduces the ability to warn other motorists of the driver's intentions, increasing the risk of a crash.
Remedy: Bmw will notify owners, and dealers will replace the rear lamp bulb carriers free of charge. Owners may contact bmw customer relations at 1-800-525-7417 or email bmw at [email protected].
Fuel economy (EPA)
| Engine | Transmission | Drive | City | Hwy | Comb. |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 3.0L 6-cyl | Manual 6-spd | Rear-Wheel Drive | 17 | 26 | 20 |
| 3.0L 6-cyl | Automatic (S6) | Rear-Wheel Drive | 17 | 26 | 20 |
| 3.0L 6-cyl | Automatic (S6) | 4-Wheel or All-Wheel Drive | 17 | 25 | 20 |
| 3.0L 6-cyl | Manual 6-spd | 4-Wheel or All-Wheel Drive | 16 | 25 | 19 |
Other BMW 535I years
Frequently asked questions
Is the 2009 BMW 535I a reliable car?
Our score for the 2009 BMW 535I is 5.8/10 (average). It is based on 72 owner complaints and 1 recall compared with other 2009 vehicles and other BMW 535I years.
What are the most common problems with the 2009 BMW 535I?
Owners most often report problems with fuel & propulsion system (42 complaints), engine & cooling (28 complaints), transmission & powertrain (6 complaints).
How many recalls does the 2009 BMW 535I have?
1 recall is on file with NHTSA, including: 13V407000 (exterior lighting:tail lights).
What gas mileage does the 2009 BMW 535I get?
The EPA rates the 2009 BMW 535I at about 17 MPG city, 26 MPG highway and 20 MPG combined, depending on engine and drivetrain.
Source: NHTSA complaints & recalls, EPA fueleconomy.gov. Data updated November 18, 2026. Complaints are unverified reports by owners.