CarProblemsDB

2016 Toyota Prius C problems, recalls & MPG

NHTSA has received 12 complaints from owners of the 2016 Toyota Prius C, most often about the other / unknown. There are no safety recalls for this model year. The EPA rates it at about 50 MPG combined.

7.9out of 10
Our verdict
Good choice
  • More complaints than 32% of 2016 vehicles
  • Most reported problem: other / unknown (33% of complaints)
  • No safety recalls on file
How we score
Complaints12
Recalls0
MPG combined50
Safety4/5

Most reported 2016 Toyota Prius C problems

Owner complaints filed with NHTSA, grouped by problem area. One complaint can mention several areas.

Other / unknown4 (33%)
Brakes3 (25%)
Tires3 (25%)
Electrical system2 (17%)
Fuel & propulsion system1 (8%)
Exterior lighting1 (8%)
Speed control (cruise, throttle)1 (8%)
Visibility, windows & wipers1 (8%)

When owners reported problems

32016
32017
12019
12022
22024
12025
12026

Complaints by the year they were filed.

Recent owner complaints

Jun 3, 2026service brakes
My name is [xxx] currently active duty military stationed in san diego. Can you please check if my car VIN number [xxx] 2016 Toyota Prius C 103k miles still covered for brake booster malfunction code 1391. I have told they are extended warranty up to 10 yrs less 150k. Toyota dealer here seems not seeing any warranty coverage issues. Please help me look into this issues… Read more

My name is [xxx] currently active duty military stationed in san diego. Can you please check if my car VIN number [xxx] 2016 Toyota Prius C 103k miles still covered for brake booster malfunction code 1391. I have told they are extended warranty up to 10 yrs less 150k. Toyota dealer here seems not seeing any warranty coverage issues. Please help me look into this issues thank you. My contact number is [xxx] . Information redacted pursuant to the freedom of information act (foia), 5 u.s.c. 552(b)(6)

NHTSA complaint #11741935
Aug 16, 2025tires

P 175/65r15 I was driving on a slight curve on the I-10 in el paso, tx when the rear bumper exploded. The car started swaying and swerving then I pulled over. I then realized that the tread on the tire was gone floating across the highway. The trie was bare with no tread with the bumper around the tire was gone. The explosion also caused the tail light to break.

NHTSA complaint #11681053
Aug 21, 2024tires

See attached document for complaint

NHTSA complaint #11609943
Aug 9, 2024tires

Prinx hicity hh2 175/65r15 84h bought this tire in november 2022. About 15000 miles into it, on aug 6, 2024, the passenger front tire just busted. After swapping with the spare tire, and upon inspection, there was no nail nor it hit the curb, but the side wall is busted. This is a manufacturing quality issue.

NHTSA complaint #11607627
Oct 20, 2022visibility/wiper
The original windshield has a “rippling distortion” where the windshield has ripple/bubble from defective glass or installation mistakes, making seeing traffic signs or streets very hard. I just bought this vehicle and noticed the problem. It created poor road vision, especially at night. Toyota needs to recall and replace all these windshields before it causes more… Read more

The original windshield has a “rippling distortion” where the windshield has ripple/bubble from defective glass or installation mistakes, making seeing traffic signs or streets very hard. I just bought this vehicle and noticed the problem. It created poor road vision, especially at night. Toyota needs to recall and replace all these windshields before it causes more accidents due to poor visibility looking through the glass.

NHTSA complaint #11490244
Feb 21, 2019vehicle speed control, unknown or other, service brakes
When I am in the process of braking and hit a rough spot in the road such as a pothole, I essentially lose control of the car for a split second. It feels jerky like it lurches forward or shakes side to side. Its not very pronounced but enough to make me feel unsafe. This happens every time I am braking and run over potholes, so its not an isolated incident that only… Read more

When I am in the process of braking and hit a rough spot in the road such as a pothole, I essentially lose control of the car for a split second. It feels jerky like it lurches forward or shakes side to side. Its not very pronounced but enough to make me feel unsafe. This happens every time I am braking and run over potholes, so its not an isolated incident that only happened on one day, and it doesn't matter how hard I'm braking or how fast I'm going unless I'm barely moving (then it doesn't jerk).

NHTSA complaint #11181608
Dec 17, 2017unknown or other
Since purchase of the car, the vehicle has shifted from drive to neutral upon braking hard. This has occurred while driving on the freeway. The car will not return to drive without turning off the engine and restarting. It is not safe to drive. Toyota of carlsbad couldn't reproduce the event after a few tries on a test drive, so they will not do anything about it. I am… Read more

Since purchase of the car, the vehicle has shifted from drive to neutral upon braking hard. This has occurred while driving on the freeway. The car will not return to drive without turning off the engine and restarting. It is not safe to drive. Toyota of carlsbad couldn't reproduce the event after a few tries on a test drive, so they will not do anything about it. I am concerned about having a fatal accident while driving on the freeway. The events happen randomly.

NHTSA complaint #11055096
Oct 30, 2017unknown or other
With the auxiliary battery well charged the gas engine will turn off when vehicle comes to a stop. In order to turn the ignition key to the off position and remove the key it is necessary to move the shift lever to the park position. At the same time it is advisable to set the parking brake. If distracted it is possible to open the door and leave the vehicle with the… Read more

With the auxiliary battery well charged the gas engine will turn off when vehicle comes to a stop. In order to turn the ignition key to the off position and remove the key it is necessary to move the shift lever to the park position. At the same time it is advisable to set the parking brake. If distracted it is possible to open the door and leave the vehicle with the electric engine still running. There is no engine noise at all. There is no signal, audio or light, to indicate the engine is still running. I have had this occur on two occasions, once during daytime, with my son accompanying me, 09/07/2017, the second timel alone, when parking the car in my garage at night, 09/13/2017. On return to the car, with my son, I search for my keys and found the car's gas engine running, emitting the normal engine noise, the key not having been removed after parking. When turning off and removing the key from the ignition, inside lights and drive lights continue to be on until the door is closed, at which time the lights, inside and out, go off after a brief period of time. The three actions, moving the shift lever, setting the parking brake and turning off the ignition all require use of the right hand, with the moving of the shift lever being mandetory. With no audible engine noise it is easy to overlook the fact that the engine is still running. An audible beep or flashing light would alert the driver to the fact that something is amiss. Of course an unlocked parked car

NHTSA complaint #11041440

2016 Toyota Prius C recalls (0)

No safety recalls have been issued for the 2016 Toyota Prius C.

Fuel economy (EPA)

EngineTransmissionDriveCityHwyComb.
1.5L 4-cylAutomatic (variable gear ratios)Front-Wheel Drive534650

Crash-test ratings (NHTSA)

VersionOverallFrontalSideRollover
2016 Toyota Prius C 5 HB FWD★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★

Other Toyota Prius C years

Frequently asked questions

Is the 2016 Toyota Prius C a reliable car?

Our score for the 2016 Toyota Prius C is 7.9/10 (good choice). It is based on 12 owner complaints and 0 recalls compared with other 2016 vehicles and other Toyota Prius C years.

What are the most common problems with the 2016 Toyota Prius C?

Owners most often report problems with other / unknown (4 complaints), brakes (3 complaints), tires (3 complaints).

How many recalls does the 2016 Toyota Prius C have?

There are no NHTSA safety recalls for this model year.

What gas mileage does the 2016 Toyota Prius C get?

The EPA rates the 2016 Toyota Prius C at about 53 MPG city, 46 MPG highway and 50 MPG combined, depending on engine and drivetrain.

Source: NHTSA complaints & recalls, EPA fueleconomy.gov. Data updated November 18, 2026. Complaints are unverified reports by owners.