CarProblemsDB

2019 Toyota 86 problems, recalls & MPG

NHTSA has received 10 complaints from owners of the 2019 Toyota 86, most often about the engine & cooling. There is 1 safety recall for this model year. The EPA rates it at about 26 MPG combined.

3.6out of 10
Our verdict
Buy with caution
  • More complaints than 34% of 2019 vehicles
  • Most reported problem: engine & cooling (30% of complaints)
  • 1 safety recall
  • 2 crashes, 2 fires, 3 injuries reported
How we score
Complaints10
Recalls1
MPG combined26
Safety—

Most reported 2019 Toyota 86 problems

Owner complaints filed with NHTSA, grouped by problem area. One complaint can mention several areas.

Engine & cooling3 (30%)
Fuel & propulsion system2 (20%)
Other / unknown2 (20%)
Airbags1 (10%)
Backup camera1 (10%)
Body & structure1 (10%)
Brakes1 (10%)
Electrical system1 (10%)
Seat belts1 (10%)
Speed control (cruise, throttle)1 (10%)
Stability control1 (10%)
Suspension1 (10%)

When owners reported problems

32019
32020
32025
12026

Complaints by the year they were filed.

Recent owner complaints

Jun 13, 2026suspension, back over prevention

Right and left strut mounts struts are making noise popping noise when turning the wheel also transmission is very hot in cabin. Back up camera blanks out on hot says

NHTSA complaint #11743916
Sep 4, 2025engine
On [xxx], my 2019 Toyota 86 experienced a sudden engine failure while I was driving, causing the vehicle to lose power and become undrivable. The vehicle was towed to camelback Toyota in phoenix, az. The dealership initially diagnosed the failure as being caused by an “overfilled oil” condition. However, the vehicle was then inspected by costa oil (the shop that performed my… Read more

On [xxx], my 2019 Toyota 86 experienced a sudden engine failure while I was driving, causing the vehicle to lose power and become undrivable. The vehicle was towed to camelback Toyota in phoenix, az. The dealership initially diagnosed the failure as being caused by an “overfilled oil” condition. However, the vehicle was then inspected by costa oil (the shop that performed my most recent oil change). Costa oil confirmed in writing that the oil level was within Toyota specifications, directly contradicting the dealer’s diagnosis. Camelback Toyota later today stated that the cause of failure was “undetermined unless the engine is disassembled.” Toyota corporate has denied goodwill repair coverage, despite the fact that the vehicle was properly maintained and the failure occurred suddenly without warning. This type of failure presents a safety hazard because the car lost power unexpectedly while in motion. It appears consistent with known engine defects in Toyota 86/subaru brz models related to oil starvation and rtv sealant contamination. I have written documentation from both Toyota and costa oil available to NHTSA upon request. Information redacted pursuant to the freedom of information act (foia), 5 u.s.c. 552(b)(6)

NHTSA complaint #11685141
Jul 25, 2025engine
The contact owns a 2019 Toyota 86. The contact stated while driving 30 MPH with her grandson inside the vehicle, the contact heard a tapping sound coming from engine and the vehicle lost motive power. The contact was able to pull over to the right side of the road while awaiting tow truck assistance. The contact was unaware of a warning light being illuminated. A dealer was… Read more

The contact owns a 2019 Toyota 86. The contact stated while driving 30 MPH with her grandson inside the vehicle, the contact heard a tapping sound coming from engine and the vehicle lost motive power. The contact was able to pull over to the right side of the road while awaiting tow truck assistance. The contact was unaware of a warning light being illuminated. A dealer was contacted. The vehicle was towed to an independent mechanic and then towed to a dealer and the vehicle was diagnosed with engine failure. The contact was informed that the engine needed to be replaced. The vehicle was repaired. The manufacturer was notified of the failure and opened a case. The contact was referred to the NHTSA hotline to report the failure. The failure mileage was 50,000.

NHTSA complaint #11676173
Jun 11, 2025air bags

My srs warning light keeps coming on every time I start my vehicle. The warning light on my dash bord it reads check srs air bag system.it has been doing this for at last 4 weeks it won't go away regardless.

NHTSA complaint #11666436
Sep 10, 2020electrical system, unknown or otherFire

My dash lights started to flicker then noticed water coming from dash onto my feet. Brought my car to Toyota dealership and was told nothing was wrong with it. 1 month and 1/2 later car caught fire due to electrical issue behind steering wheel. I am holding all star Toyota liable.

NHTSA complaint #11354180
Feb 19, 2020fuel/propulsion system

Toyota knowingly & willfully has manufactured and sold defective vehicles to consumers with a known safety risk defective fuel pump making the vehicles unsafe to drive, have not notified consumers of this major safety risk, have not compensated owners for the lack of use & the decrease in value of said car. The management should be fined & possibly held personally responsible for criminal charges

NHTSA complaint #11310143
Feb 4, 2020seat beltsCrash3 injured
Tl* the contact owns a 2019 Toyota 86 while driving 45 MPH crashed into the front quarter panel of a 2004 Toyota 4 runner. The drivers and passenger seat belts released upon impact without warning. The contact received burns and wrist injuries the passenger sustained chest and head injuries and medical attention was provided for both occupants. The driver of the Toyota… Read more

Tl* the contact owns a 2019 Toyota 86 while driving 45 MPH crashed into the front quarter panel of a 2004 Toyota 4 runner. The drivers and passenger seat belts released upon impact without warning. The contact received burns and wrist injuries the passenger sustained chest and head injuries and medical attention was provided for both occupants. The driver of the Toyota 4runner sustained unknown injuries and medical attention was provided. The drivers, passenger and side air bags deployed. A police report was filed. There was no fire. The vehicle was towed to an independent lot. The local dealer and manufacturer was not contacted. The failure mileage was 13,000.

NHTSA complaint #11307074
Oct 27, 2019structure, electronic stability control (esc), engineCrash

I was still amd got hitby cadillac su

NHTSA complaint #11271280

2019 Toyota 86 recalls (1)

Recall 21V5870002021Fuel system, gasoline:delivery:fuel pump

Subaru of america, inc. (subaru) is recalling certain 2019-2020 ascent, 2018 forester, 2018-2020 impreza, legacy, outback, 2018-2019 brz, wrx, and Toyota 86 vehicles. The low-pressure fuel pump inside the fuel tank may fail.

Risk: Fuel pump failure can cause an engine stall while driving, increasing the risk of a crash.

Remedy: Dealers will replace the low-pressure fuel pump, free of charge. Owner notification letters were mailed september 24, 2021. Subaru and toyota owners may call customer service at 1-844-373-6614. Subaru's number for this recall is wrg-21.

Fuel economy (EPA)

EngineTransmissionDriveCityHwyComb.
2.0L 4-cylAutomatic (S6)Rear-Wheel Drive243227
2.0L 4-cylManual 6-spdRear-Wheel Drive212824

Crash-test ratings (NHTSA)

VersionOverallFrontalSideRollover
2019 Toyota 86 2 DR RWD—★★★★★—★★★★★

Other Toyota 86 years

Frequently asked questions

Is the 2019 Toyota 86 a reliable car?

Our score for the 2019 Toyota 86 is 3.6/10 (buy with caution). It is based on 10 owner complaints and 1 recall compared with other 2019 vehicles and other Toyota 86 years.

What are the most common problems with the 2019 Toyota 86?

Owners most often report problems with engine & cooling (3 complaints), fuel & propulsion system (2 complaints), other / unknown (2 complaints).

How many recalls does the 2019 Toyota 86 have?

1 recall is on file with NHTSA, including: 21V587000 (fuel system, gasoline:delivery:fuel pump).

What gas mileage does the 2019 Toyota 86 get?

The EPA rates the 2019 Toyota 86 at about 23 MPG city, 30 MPG highway and 26 MPG combined, depending on engine and drivetrain.

Source: NHTSA complaints & recalls, EPA fueleconomy.gov. Data updated November 18, 2026. Complaints are unverified reports by owners.