4.6out of 10
Our verdict
Buy with caution
- More complaints than 49% of 2004 vehicles
- Most reported problem: suspension (41% of complaints)
- No safety recalls on file
- 4 crashes, 3 fires, 6 injuries reported
How we score
Most reported 2004 Mercedes-Benz SL-Class problems
Owner complaints filed with NHTSA, grouped by problem area. One complaint can mention several areas.
Transmission & powertrain3 (5%)
Speed control (cruise, throttle)2 (4%)
When owners reported problems
12004
12005
22008
52010
42011
52012
82014
52015
32016
62017
42018
32019
32020
12022
22023
12025
22026
Complaints by the year they were filed.
Recent owner complaints
Aug 5, 2026service brakes, hydraulic
The contact owns a 2004 Mercedes-Benz sl500. The contact stated that after starting the vehicle, the message "brakes reached historic threshold" was displayed, which indicated that the brake control unit had malfunctioned. Additionally, while depressing the brake pedal, the brake pedal was spongy, causing the stopping distance to become extended. The vehicle was taken to the… Read more
The contact owns a 2004 Mercedes-Benz sl500. The contact stated that after starting the vehicle, the message "brakes reached historic threshold" was displayed, which indicated that the brake control unit had malfunctioned. Additionally, while depressing the brake pedal, the brake pedal was spongy, causing the stopping distance to become extended. The vehicle was taken to the local dealer and was diagnosed with brake control unit failure. The contact was informed that the brake control unit needed to be replaced. The vehicle was not repaired. The manufacturer was notified of the failure, but no assistance was provided. The contact stated that a 25-year warranty for the failure was previously issued by the manufacturer that was associated with the failure, but was not honored. The failure mileage was 62,800.
NHTSA complaint #11754971
Jan 24, 2026service brakes
Question 1: the sensotronic brake control (sbc) unit, which is a high-pressure "brake-by-wire" hydraulic system. Component a7/3. The component is currently installed in the vehicle and is available for inspection. Question 2: the vehicle experienced a sudden, catastrophic loss of hydraulic brake pressure while in operation. This failure required extreme physical force on the… Read more
Question 1: the sensotronic brake control (sbc) unit, which is a high-pressure "brake-by-wire" hydraulic system. Component a7/3. The component is currently installed in the vehicle and is available for inspection. Question 2: the vehicle experienced a sudden, catastrophic loss of hydraulic brake pressure while in operation. This failure required extreme physical force on the pedal and significant increase in stopping distance. The vehicle is currently in my garage with chocked wheels until I figure out what's next. A couple days ago, I had the car at a dealer and requested a review of this system and they released the car back to me stating the system status was, "ok" despite me stating to the dealer that the safety-monitoring counter was found to be at 0 on a 63,000-mile car. In all of my research, I believe this "silenced" the vehicle's ability to provide a timely service warning (code c249f) before total hydraulic failure occurred. Question 3: Mercedes-Benz of denver performed a diagnostic on january 21, 2026. While the dealer initially claimed the system was "ok," the total failure occurred within 72 hours of their inspection. The reason it was at benz of denver is because my independent mechanic confirmed the 0 actuation count which was suspicious to me. I wanted to understand the mechanical integrity of the newly purchased vehicle. Question 4: yes, inspected by an authorized Mercedes-Benz dealership technician on january 21, 2026. Question 5: to my knowledge there
NHTSA complaint #11713126
Dec 3, 2025electrical system, service brakes
The safety component that is covered under the sbc warranty is the entire brake master cylinder specifically the part that is bad is the brake pedal position sensor the car is undriveable without it, they have a 25-year warranty on it yet they have no parts and no way to fix it which is obviously unacceptable they've also refused to provide a loaner car until they come up with… Read more
The safety component that is covered under the sbc warranty is the entire brake master cylinder specifically the part that is bad is the brake pedal position sensor the car is undriveable without it, they have a 25-year warranty on it yet they have no parts and no way to fix it which is obviously unacceptable they've also refused to provide a loaner car until they come up with a way to fix my car leaving me on the side of the road with nothing to drive it's unacceptable! My safety and everybody's safety on the road is affected by this because the car won't stop if you drive it and you have really strong legs you can get it to slow down and eventually stop it's completely unsafe the brake pedal cannot tell the computer where it is in its travel which means the system doesn't know that you're applying the brakes which don't work. Yes the problem has been confirmed by two shops one of which has a snap-on scanner which I can attach the scan to showing the issue and currently the car is sitting at a shop that uses Mercedes-Benz only star system the same system that they use in the dealership there is no question at any level what is wrong with the vehicle. The car is not safe to drive to the dealership and now in the winter this $132,000 convertible isn't going to be driven in the salt just to get to a dealership to find out what they're not going to do for me I've already confirmed and share the scans and images and everybody I've spoken with at the dealerships agrees that it'
NHTSA complaint #11702808
Nov 29, 2023electrical system
Mercedes sl600 BCM has electrical issues leading to a fire it is available for inspection. The car can burn down in a garage putting me and all others in or near the dwelling at risk. Yes the problem has been confirmed independently. No BCM issues lead to red light on dash.
NHTSA complaint #11557421
Apr 23, 2023electrical systemFire
The 2003-2006 r230 series seem to have a problem with the BCM (battery control module) as start an electrical fire in the trunk. Very common issue and a safety hazard - this is what happened with my car. Vehicle has dual battery, starter in front, convenience battery in trunk and fuses that operate at 130 amps - the BCM capacitors and circuit board age and at some point can no… Read more
The 2003-2006 r230 series seem to have a problem with the BCM (battery control module) as start an electrical fire in the trunk. Very common issue and a safety hazard - this is what happened with my car. Vehicle has dual battery, starter in front, convenience battery in trunk and fuses that operate at 130 amps - the BCM capacitors and circuit board age and at some point can no longer handle the high current and catch fire.
NHTSA complaint #11518528
May 7, 2022fuel/propulsion system
On many 2003 and 2004 models. Broken fuel tank baffle inside fuel tank. This is well documented and could possibly cause explosion.
NHTSA complaint #11463728
Jul 30, 2020fuel/propulsion system
On july 22, 2020 the vehicle (2004 Mercedes-Benz sl500 (r230)began making a loud banging noise in the rear when stopping and turning. I delivered the vehicle to a local shop where the vehicle was diagnosed as having a broken baffle in the fuel tank. The only solution is to replace the entire fuel tank. Many other owners of this model have experienced the same issue and is… Read more
On july 22, 2020 the vehicle (2004 Mercedes-Benz sl500 (r230)began making a loud banging noise in the rear when stopping and turning. I delivered the vehicle to a local shop where the vehicle was diagnosed as having a broken baffle in the fuel tank. The only solution is to replace the entire fuel tank. Many other owners of this model have experienced the same issue and is clearly a manufacturer defect; this cannot be caused by excess wear on the vehicle. Because there is now a large section of the fuel tank freely swinging inside, there is a chance that this could cause a spark and subsequent explosion. I cannot safely drive this vehicle until the fuel tank is replaced at a very large cost. This model should have been recalled when this issue was first coming to light over 15 years ago.
NHTSA complaint #11342296
Jun 29, 2020suspension
Tl* the contact owns a 2004 Mercedes-Benz sl500. The contact stated on various occasions while his vehicle was stationery and in park, either the right side or the left side of the vehicle would raise up then descend to ground over a thirty second period independently without warning. The contact also stated that the hydraulic fluid leaked out of the engine. The vehicle had… Read more
Tl* the contact owns a 2004 Mercedes-Benz sl500. The contact stated on various occasions while his vehicle was stationery and in park, either the right side or the left side of the vehicle would raise up then descend to ground over a thirty second period independently without warning. The contact also stated that the hydraulic fluid leaked out of the engine. The vehicle had yet to be taken to a dealer to be diagnosed or serviced for the failure. Upon investigation, the contact linked his failure to NHTSA campaign number :08v405000 (suspension) however, the VIN was not included in the recall. The manufacturer had yet to be notified of the failure. The vehicle had yet to be repaired. The failure mileage was approximately 92,000.
NHTSA complaint #11331597
2004 Mercedes-Benz SL-Class recalls (0)
No safety recalls have been issued for the 2004 Mercedes-Benz SL-Class.
Crash-test ratings (NHTSA)
| Version | Overall | Frontal | Side | Rollover |
|---|
| 2004 Mercedes-Benz SL-Class Convertible w/SAB | — | — | — | — |
Other Mercedes-Benz SL-Class years
Frequently asked questions
Is the 2004 Mercedes-Benz SL-Class a reliable car?
Our score for the 2004 Mercedes-Benz SL-Class is 4.6/10 (buy with caution). It is based on 56 owner complaints and 0 recalls compared with other 2004 vehicles and other Mercedes-Benz SL-Class years.
What are the most common problems with the 2004 Mercedes-Benz SL-Class?
Owners most often report problems with suspension (23 complaints), brakes (16 complaints), fuel & propulsion system (12 complaints).
How many recalls does the 2004 Mercedes-Benz SL-Class have?
There are no NHTSA safety recalls for this model year.
Source: NHTSA complaints & recalls, EPA fueleconomy.gov. Data updated November 18, 2026. Complaints are unverified reports by owners.