CarProblemsDB

2004 Cadillac XLR problems, recalls & MPG

NHTSA has received 33 complaints from owners of the 2004 Cadillac XLR, most often about the body & structure. There are 5 safety recalls for this model year. The EPA rates it at about 18 MPG combined.

3.9out of 10
Our verdict
Buy with caution
  • More complaints than 37% of 2004 vehicles
  • Most reported problem: body & structure (30% of complaints)
  • 5 safety recalls
  • 2 crashes reported
How we score
Complaints33
Recalls5
MPG combined18
Safety—

Most reported 2004 Cadillac XLR problems

Owner complaints filed with NHTSA, grouped by problem area. One complaint can mention several areas.

Fuel & propulsion system8 (24%)
Brakes4 (12%)
Exterior lighting4 (12%)
Electrical system3 (9%)
Stability control3 (9%)
Other / unknown2 (6%)
Speed control (cruise, throttle)2 (6%)
Transmission & powertrain2 (6%)
Visibility, windows & wipers2 (6%)
Engine & cooling1 (3%)
Steering1 (3%)
Tires1 (3%)

When owners reported problems

22004
12007
12009
32010
32013
52014
12015
32017
12018
42019
12020
32021
32022
12024
12026

Complaints by the year they were filed.

Recent owner complaints

Jan 15, 2026structure
The contact owns a 2004 Cadillac XLR. The contact stated that while driving approximately 70 MPH, there was an abnormal sound like a shotgun being fired overhead. The contact pulled over and observed that the retractable fiberglass roof panel had detached from the frame of the vehicle. The contact stated that the headliner, cables, and pulleys used to retract the roof were… Read more

The contact owns a 2004 Cadillac XLR. The contact stated that while driving approximately 70 MPH, there was an abnormal sound like a shotgun being fired overhead. The contact pulled over and observed that the retractable fiberglass roof panel had detached from the frame of the vehicle. The contact stated that the headliner, cables, and pulleys used to retract the roof were exposed. The contact was unable to recover the panel. The contact called the dealer and the manufacturer and was informed that there were no recalls on the VIN for the failure. The contact was informed that the roof panel could be replaced out-of-pocket. The vehicle was not repaired. The failure mileage was approximately 88,000.

NHTSA complaint #11711077
May 22, 2024electrical system, structure, unknown or other
The roof panel that was only attached with adhesive has detached from the frame of the car. This has also caused the retractable convertible top to stop working. I have read about the roof of many of these cars flying off while driving down the road. It is only a matter of time before this poor defect causes serious injury and/ or significant property damage. I called Cadillac… Read more

The roof panel that was only attached with adhesive has detached from the frame of the car. This has also caused the retractable convertible top to stop working. I have read about the roof of many of these cars flying off while driving down the road. It is only a matter of time before this poor defect causes serious injury and/ or significant property damage. I called Cadillac customer service and they refused to offer any help. I recently spoke to a local body shop about getting it repaired and the estimate was upward of 1000 dollars

NHTSA complaint #11590209
Aug 19, 2022structure

The top roof panel separated while driving on the highway, and almost struck another vehicle causing it to swerve to miss it. The vehicle then proceeded to follow me as he though I was to blame. Once I got off the highway he got out of his car an violently started screaming at me for almost causing an accident.

NHTSA complaint #11480261
Aug 17, 2022fuel system, gasoline
The contact owns a 2004 Cadillac XLR. The contact stated that fuel had begun to leak from the fuel pump without warning. The contact took the vehicle to an independent mechanic who diagnosed the failure and informed him that while the motor was running, the fuel would leak from the rear driver's side wheel; the leak would stop once the engine was shut off. The mechanic later… Read more

The contact owns a 2004 Cadillac XLR. The contact stated that fuel had begun to leak from the fuel pump without warning. The contact took the vehicle to an independent mechanic who diagnosed the failure and informed him that while the motor was running, the fuel would leak from the rear driver's side wheel; the leak would stop once the engine was shut off. The mechanic later discovered NHTSA campaign number: 11e009000(fuel system, gasoline) which he linked to the failure. The dealer was notified and an appointment was made for a diagnostic. The manufacturer had yet to be notified of the failure. The vehicle had yet to be repaired. The failure mileage was 24,089.

NHTSA complaint #11479731
Aug 5, 2022fuel system, gasoline, engine
The contact owns a 2004 Cadillac XLR. The contact stated there were strong fumes coming from the vehicle. The contact parked his vehicle in the garage and then leave it partially cracked due to the fumes. The contact changed the gas cap; however, the fumes continues. There were no warning lights illuminated. The contact called the local dealer regarding the failure; however,… Read more

The contact owns a 2004 Cadillac XLR. The contact stated there were strong fumes coming from the vehicle. The contact parked his vehicle in the garage and then leave it partially cracked due to the fumes. The contact changed the gas cap; however, the fumes continues. There were no warning lights illuminated. The contact called the local dealer regarding the failure; however, it was not diagnosed. The vehicle was not repaired. The manufacturer was not notified of the failure. The approximate failure mileage was 70,000.

NHTSA complaint #11477797
Nov 29, 2021visibility
The contact owns a 2004 Cadillac XLR. The contact stated while driving 65 MPH, there was an abnormally loud whistling sound coming inside the vehicle. The contact looked up and noticed that the sunroof glass had detached from the vehicle. The contact pulled over to the side of the road and retrieved the sunroof glass. The vehicle was then towed to an auto body shop to be… Read more

The contact owns a 2004 Cadillac XLR. The contact stated while driving 65 MPH, there was an abnormally loud whistling sound coming inside the vehicle. The contact looked up and noticed that the sunroof glass had detached from the vehicle. The contact pulled over to the side of the road and retrieved the sunroof glass. The vehicle was then towed to an auto body shop to be inspected. The contact was informed that there was a defect in the glue used to secure the sunroof to the sunroof assembly. The vehicle was not repaired. The manufacturer was not made aware of the failure. The failure mileage was approximately 100,000.

NHTSA complaint #11441992
Nov 14, 2021structure

My roof panel is separating from the roof frame of my 04 Cadillac XLR. If it come off it will cause property damage to another vehicle or death! It a GM defect that should be recall !!!! Thanks!

NHTSA complaint #11440408
Sep 28, 2021structure

Was driving on interstate and top panel on convertible top flew off.

NHTSA complaint #11434620

2004 Cadillac XLR recalls (5)

Recall 11E009000Fuel system, gasoline:delivery:fuel pump

Ti automotive is recalling certain fuel pumps, part numbers tu456 and tu303, sold under various brand names as aftermarket and replacement equipment for the motor vehicles listed above. The defective fuel pump may seize, stopping the fuel flow to the engine creating a stalling condition.

Risk: A vehicle crash could occur should the engine stall while in use.

Remedy: Ti automotive will notify owners of record and will replace any defective fuel pump with a new or reworked fuel pump free of charge. The safety recall began on february 22, 2011. Owners may contact ti automotive at 1-866-867-3759 or log on to www.recallresponse.com.

Recall 06V2630002006Exterior lighting:turn signal

On certain passenger vehicles, the daylight running lights (drl), turn signal, and parking lamps use the same bulb. The bulb may become damaged from vibration within a loose fitting socket or air entering the bulb due to an inadequate seal. Both of these conditions will cause the bulb to burn out prematurely.

Risk: If this were to occur, the driver would notice that the arrow in the instrument panel would flash faster than normal when the turn signal is activated. The loss of the drl and turn signals could fail to warn others of the driver's presence or intentions and could lead to a vehicle crash.

Remedy: Dealers will replace the socket and bulb in both lamps free of charge. The recall began on july 31, 2006. Owners may contact cadillac at 1-866-982-2339.

Recall 05V0460002005Vehicle speed control:accelerator pedal

Certain passenger vehicles fail to comply with the requirements of federal motor vehicle safety standard no. 124, 'accelerator control systems.' if one of the two accelerator pedal return springs fails and the temperature is -22 degrees f to -40 degrees f, the engine may not return to idle within three seconds, as required.

Risk: If this were to occur, greater brake pedal force and a longer distance may be required to stop the vehicle.

Remedy: Dealers will replace the accelerator pedal assembly. This recall began on march 8, 2005. Owners may contact cadillac at 1-866-982-2339 or pontiac at 1-800-620-7668.

Recall 04V5250002004Service brakes, hydraulic:foundation components:hoses, lines/piping, and fittings

Certain passenger vehicles were produced with one or both rear brake hydraulic lines that can come in contact with or be affected by heat from the left engine exhaust manifold and the left exhaust pipe. The brake fluid could reach elevated temperatures and boil.

Risk: If the brake fluid boils in a rear brake line, the effectiveness of the rear brake system would be reduced which could result in a brake line leak and loss of brake fluid. If enough fluid leaks from the rear brake system so that brake pedal application can no longer build pressure to the rear brakes. The operator of the vehicle will experience limited braking which could result in a crash.

Remedy: Dealers will (1) inspect the left engine exhaust manifold clip for proper alignment and placement on the body-mounted stud. If incorrect, they will reposition the clip on the brake lines and reinstall the clip on the stud; (2) the dealer will verify that both rear brake lines have the proper clearance to the left exhaust pipe. They will reposition the lines by bending as necessary; (3) dealers will remove the machining tab from the rear differential housing. Also, dealers are to inspect the brake lines for wear in these related areas and repair or replace if there is any sign of wear-through on the nylon overcoating. The recall began on january 18, 2005. Owners should contact cadillac at 1-866-982-2239 or chevrolet at 1-800-630-2438.

Recall 04V2730002004Steering:linkages

On certain passenger vehicles involved in this campaign, the lower control arm ball stud nut/washer assemblies with washers were made of the wrong material. The washers may fracture and become loose or fall away from the vehicle, reducing clamp load. Separation of the control arm ball stud and steering knuckle, due to disengagement of the tapered attachment and retaining nut, is possible.

Risk: If the control arm separates from the knuckle, the affected corner of the vehicle will drop and the control arm would be forced downward, contacting the wheel. The affected wheel could tilt outward and create a dragging action that would tend to slow the vehicle and create a tendency for the vehicle to turn in the direction of the affected wheel. In extreme situations, the affected wheel assembly could separate from the vehicle. Separation of the wheel assembly would also sever that wheel;s hydraulic brake hose and result in diminished braking performance of the vehicle, which could result in a crash.

Remedy: Dealers will inspect the ball stud joints and measure the torque of the nut for all front lower control arms in all models affected as well as the rear lower control arms on the xlr and corvette. If the torque is not at specification, the dealers will replace the ball stud, the knuckle, and the nut. If the torque is at specification, the dealers will replace the nut/washer assembly only. The recall will begin on august 25, 2004. Owners should contact cadillac at 1-866-982-2339 or chevrolet at 1-800-630-2438.

Fuel economy (EPA)

EngineTransmissionDriveCityHwyComb.
4.6L 8-cylAutomatic 5-spdRear-Wheel Drive152318

Crash-test ratings (NHTSA)

VersionOverallFrontalSideRollover
2004 Cadillac XLR Convertible 2-DR. w/SAB————

Other Cadillac XLR years

Frequently asked questions

Is the 2004 Cadillac XLR a reliable car?

Our score for the 2004 Cadillac XLR is 3.9/10 (buy with caution). It is based on 33 owner complaints and 5 recalls compared with other 2004 vehicles and other Cadillac XLR years.

What are the most common problems with the 2004 Cadillac XLR?

Owners most often report problems with body & structure (10 complaints), fuel & propulsion system (8 complaints), brakes (4 complaints).

How many recalls does the 2004 Cadillac XLR have?

5 recalls are on file with NHTSA, including: 11E009000 (fuel system, gasoline:delivery:fuel pump); 06V263000 (exterior lighting:turn signal); 05V046000 (vehicle speed control:accelerator pedal).

What gas mileage does the 2004 Cadillac XLR get?

The EPA rates the 2004 Cadillac XLR at about 15 MPG city, 23 MPG highway and 18 MPG combined, depending on engine and drivetrain.

Source: NHTSA complaints & recalls, EPA fueleconomy.gov. Data updated November 18, 2026. Complaints are unverified reports by owners.