2.9out of 10
Our verdict
Avoid this year
- More complaints than 80% of 2017 vehicles
- Most reported problem: transmission & powertrain (37% of complaints)
- 2 safety recalls
- 3 crashes, 10 injuries reported
How we score
Most reported 2017 BMW X1 problems
Owner complaints filed with NHTSA, grouped by problem area. One complaint can mention several areas.
Forward collision avoidance3 (2%)
Fuel & propulsion system1 (1%)
Lane departure & lane assist1 (1%)
Visibility, windows & wipers1 (1%)
When owners reported problems
12018
102019
42020
142021
442022
302023
302024
192025
42026
Complaints by the year they were filed.
Recent owner complaints
Sep 9, 2026unknown or other, service brakes
I am reporting a recurring safety warning on my 2017 BMW X1 xdrive28i. The vehicle repeatedly displays the message “secure vehicle against rolling” on the dashboard even though the gear selector indicates that the vehicle is in park. A diagnostic scan with bluedriver also recorded BMW fault code 420106 – “shift lock solenoid: unlock stuck.” the warning has returned multiple… Read more
I am reporting a recurring safety warning on my 2017 BMW X1 xdrive28i. The vehicle repeatedly displays the message “secure vehicle against rolling” on the dashboard even though the gear selector indicates that the vehicle is in park. A diagnostic scan with bluedriver also recorded BMW fault code 420106 – “shift lock solenoid: unlock stuck.” the warning has returned multiple times and appears to indicate a problem with the vehicle’s park/shift-lock or parking-lock recognition system. Because this warning concerns the possibility of the vehicle rolling while parked, I consider it a potential safety issue. Until the problem is diagnosed and repaired, I have been using the electronic parking brake every time I park as an additional precaution. The vehicle otherwise recognizes the park position and has remained drivable, but the warning continues to reappear. I am requesting that NHTSA investigate whether this issue is occurring in other BMW X1 vehicles and whether it may involve a defect in the gear-selector, shift-lock, parking-lock, or related sensing system. Vehicle: 2017 BMW X1 xdrive28i VIN: [xxx] information redacted pursuant to the freedom of information act (foia), 5 u.s.c. 552(b)(6)
NHTSA complaint #11762954
Jul 24, 2026engine
The bmx1 overheated while parked and on with no warning of any levels being low or any obvious issues for it to overheat. I just saw the starter and overheated recall which LED me to check my suv.
NHTSA complaint #11752650
Mar 20, 2026suspension, service brakes, engine
What you’re noticing (and why it matters) 1. Engine mounts wearing out engine mounts can wear over time, but premature failure (early loosening, vibration, clunking) can point to: defective parts poor design for that model year this is a common complaint in some BMW models, especially as mileage increases. 2. Brake system & sensor issues warning lights staying on even… Read more
What you’re noticing (and why it matters) 1. Engine mounts wearing out engine mounts can wear over time, but premature failure (early loosening, vibration, clunking) can point to: defective parts poor design for that model year this is a common complaint in some BMW models, especially as mileage increases. 2. Brake system & sensor issues warning lights staying on even after replacing sensors can mean: faulty wiring or control module (not just the sensor itself) ongoing system miscommunication BMW braking systems rely heavily on electronics, so one issue can trigger repeated alerts. 3. Oil gasket / housing leaks you mentioned oil leaking from a plastic housing—this is important. BMW engines (including the X1) often use: plastic oil filter housings plastic cooling components these are known to: crack from heat over time cause oil leaks and coolant loss this isn’t always clearly explained in sales descriptions. 4. Plastic engine components many modern engines use plastic parts for: weight reduction fuel efficiency but downside: more prone to cracking, warping, or leaking especially under high heat conditions ️ should there be a recall? For something to become a recall through the national highway traffic safety administration (NHTSA), it must: be a widespread defect pose a safety risk (not just wear and tear) right now: some of these issues (like oil leaks or mounts) are often treated as maintenance or design concerns, not recalls brake system fa
NHTSA complaint #11725881
Jan 24, 2026service brakes
Secure vehicle against rolling error
NHTSA complaint #11713046
Nov 26, 2025wheels, service brakes, engine
I am writing to formally file a report regarding the severe mechanical damage to the vehicle I purchased on june 14th, 2024, identified as a 2017 BMW- X1 sdrive28i, with VIN number [xxx] . It has come to my attention that this damage was not disclosed at the time of purchase, which constitutes a violation of consumer protection laws. As a consumer, I have the right to receive… Read more
I am writing to formally file a report regarding the severe mechanical damage to the vehicle I purchased on june 14th, 2024, identified as a 2017 BMW- X1 sdrive28i, with VIN number [xxx] . It has come to my attention that this damage was not disclosed at the time of purchase, which constitutes a violation of consumer protection laws. As a consumer, I have the right to receive truthful and accurate information about the products I purchase. The failure to disclose significant mechanical issues is a violation of the federal trade commission's regulations and applicable state consumer protection laws, including the prohibition against deceptive acts and practices. This vehicle poses as a safety risk to myself, and other's. Specifically, I have experienced the following issues with the vehicle: 1. Leaking oil 2. Loud engine. 3. Overheating. 4. Suspension issues. 5. Control arm alignment. 6. Shock and strut assembly. 7. Wheel alignment. 8. Turbocharger alignment 9. Engine assembly. I've encountered all of these issues since the sale of the vehicle in 2024. Information redacted pursuant to the freedom of information act (foia), 5 u.s.c. 552(b)(6)
NHTSA complaint #11701704
Oct 7, 2025service brakes
Every time I get in the vehicle or turn the vehicle off I get a message "secure vehicle against rolling contact service specialist". Even if I press the emergency brake it still continues, this appears to be a known problem with the BMW X1 and not sure if it will cause my car to roll away.
NHTSA complaint #11691848
Aug 16, 2025suspension, power train
My car suddenly displayed a drivetrain malfunction error, and I cannot identify the reason because the car was driving normally in a residential area.
NHTSA complaint #11681098
Aug 14, 2025engine
Engine motor mounts failed
NHTSA complaint #11680779
2017 BMW X1 recalls (2)
BMW of north america, llc (BMW) is recalling certain 2016-2019 X1 sdrive28i and X1 xdrive28i vehicles. In the event of a crash where the occupants head contacts the b-pillar, the pillar may not absorb an adequate amount of the impact. As such, these vehicles fail to comply with the requirements of federal motor vehicle safety standard (fmvss) number 201, "occupant protection in interior impact."
Risk: In the event of a crash, the insufficient impact absorption can increase the risk of injury.
Remedy: Bmw will notify owners, and dealers will replace the vertical trim pieces on the upper portion of the interior b-pillars, free of charge. Interim letters notifying owners of the safety risk were mailed july 1, 2019. Second notices will be sent as parts become available, starting on september 27, 2019. Owners may contact bmw customer service at 1-800-525-7417.
BMW of north america, llc (BMW) is recalling certain model year 2016-2017 X1 sdrive28i, X1 xdrive28i, mini hardtop 4 door cooper, mini hardtop 4 door cooper s, mini cooper clubman, and cooper s clubman, 2017 rolls-royce ghost, and 2016 528i vehicles. The vehicle-sensitive locking mechanism of the seat belt emergency locking retractor (elr) for the driver's seat may not lock as designed. As such, these vehicles fail to comply with the requirements of the federal motor vehicle safety standard (fmvss) number 209, "seat belt assemblies."
Risk: In the event of a crash where heavy braking is applied, the emergency locking retractor (elr) may activate when the occupant is more forward in the seat, possibly increasing the risk of injury.
Remedy: Bmw will notify owners, and dealers will replace the driver's seat belt assembly, free of charge. The recall began july 3, 2019. Owners may contact bmw customer service at 1-800-525-7417.
Fuel economy (EPA)
| Engine | Transmission | Drive | City | Hwy | Comb. |
|---|
| 2.0L 4-cyl | Automatic (S8) | Front-Wheel Drive | 23 | 32 | 26 |
| 2.0L 4-cyl | Automatic (S8) | All-Wheel Drive | 22 | 31 | 25 |
Crash-test ratings (NHTSA)
| Version | Overall | Frontal | Side | Rollover |
|---|
| 2017 BMW X1 SUV RWD | — | — | — | — |
| 2017 BMW X1 SUV AWD | — | — | — | — |
Frequently asked questions
Is the 2017 BMW X1 a reliable car?
Our score for the 2017 BMW X1 is 2.9/10 (avoid this year). It is based on 156 owner complaints and 2 recalls compared with other 2017 vehicles and other BMW X1 years.
What are the most common problems with the 2017 BMW X1?
Owners most often report problems with transmission & powertrain (57 complaints), other / unknown (50 complaints), brakes (26 complaints).
How many recalls does the 2017 BMW X1 have?
2 recalls are on file with NHTSA, including: 19V349000 (structure:body:roof and pillars); 16V747000 (seat belts:front:retractor).
What gas mileage does the 2017 BMW X1 get?
The EPA rates the 2017 BMW X1 at about 23 MPG city, 32 MPG highway and 26 MPG combined, depending on engine and drivetrain.
Source: NHTSA complaints & recalls, EPA fueleconomy.gov. Data updated November 18, 2026. Complaints are unverified reports by owners.