CarProblemsDB

2011 BMW 535I US problems, recalls & MPG

NHTSA has received 36 complaints from owners of the 2011 BMW 535I US, most often about the tires. There are no safety recalls for this model year.

7.1out of 10
Our verdict
Average
  • More complaints than 54% of 2011 vehicles
  • Most reported problem: tires (50% of complaints)
  • No safety recalls on file
How we score
Complaints36
Recalls0
MPG combined—
Safety—

Most reported 2011 BMW 535I US problems

Owner complaints filed with NHTSA, grouped by problem area. One complaint can mention several areas.

Tires18 (50%)
Engine & cooling7 (19%)
Wheels4 (11%)
Electrical system3 (8%)
Fuel & propulsion system3 (8%)
Transmission & powertrain3 (8%)
Other / unknown2 (6%)
Steering2 (6%)
Brakes1 (3%)
Exterior lighting1 (3%)
Suspension1 (3%)

When owners reported problems

132011
92012
42013
12015
12016
62017
12018
12019

Complaints by the year they were filed.

Recent owner complaints

May 29, 2019electrical system, exterior lighting, engine
I have had several problems. 1. Both head lights became filled with condensation/water. I took it to a BMW dealership. They performed a BMW diagnosis. I was told that the most likely case was the cold air. They checked for excess air leaks in both head lights but did not find excess air leaks. (see attached statement) they also replaced a gasket, oil filter housing. The oil… Read more

I have had several problems. 1. Both head lights became filled with condensation/water. I took it to a BMW dealership. They performed a BMW diagnosis. I was told that the most likely case was the cold air. They checked for excess air leaks in both head lights but did not find excess air leaks. (see attached statement) they also replaced a gasket, oil filter housing. The oil filter housing was allowing oil to leak out from the engine 5.8. They performed removal and replacement of the oil filter housing gasket and washed down the engine of the oil residue. The incidents were diagnosed and replace accordingly on jan. 24. 2019. Just recently, about 5 days ago today, my car started making a weird loud noise like a garbage truck makes when it goes from stop to stop. It made that sound when driving, as well as when parked with the engine running. At the same time, I was no longer able to open my truck with neither the inside button or my keys. I took my car to a repair shop that was close by. The owner used to work for BMW service center as a mechanic before starting his own business. Strangely, the car did not make the sound in his presence although it was left running. I left his shop and was heading home when suddenly I got a red error message warning me that the engine had over heated and that I should drive slowly and/or pull over as over heating could cause the vehicle to catch on fire. The message also said the vehicle needed coolant. I purchase the coolant according to the

NHTSA complaint #11210575
Jan 8, 2018power train
My BMW has about 75k miles on it. I was driving it one day after work and all of a sudden the car stalled on the highway. Car did not shut down or anything but loss of power, it's like my vehicle went into neutral gear, I stepped on the gas and the car will not move. This almost resulted in a fatal crash. 'drivetran malfunction' came on the dashboard. This is very weird for a… Read more

My BMW has about 75k miles on it. I was driving it one day after work and all of a sudden the car stalled on the highway. Car did not shut down or anything but loss of power, it's like my vehicle went into neutral gear, I stepped on the gas and the car will not move. This almost resulted in a fatal crash. 'drivetran malfunction' came on the dashboard. This is very weird for a car that only has 75k miles on it. I haven't had any issues prior to this, car completely stalled while I was driving it, I thank god I was in the process of exiting off the highway, other wise I would've had a very fatal crash.

NHTSA complaint #11061260
Nov 4, 2017engine

There are wires on the engine that are cracking and was told by the BMW dealer that this can cause a fire.

NHTSA complaint #11043149
Nov 4, 2017power train

Car shows error of drivetrain malfunction and the car starts to shake.

NHTSA complaint #11043150
Aug 15, 2017suspension, wheels
Tl* the contact owns a 2011 BMW 535I US. While driving over 40 MPH, the vehicle began to shake. The contact removed his foot from the accelerator pedal to bring the speed down to 30 MPH, but the shaking became aggressive. The contact depressed the brake pedal, but the shaking continued. The contact also mentioned that he heard a clicking noise coming from the wheels, but could… Read more

Tl* the contact owns a 2011 BMW 535I US. While driving over 40 MPH, the vehicle began to shake. The contact removed his foot from the accelerator pedal to bring the speed down to 30 MPH, but the shaking became aggressive. The contact depressed the brake pedal, but the shaking continued. The contact also mentioned that he heard a clicking noise coming from the wheels, but could not determine if it was the front or rear wheels. There were no warning indicators illuminated. The dealer was not contacted. The vehicle was not diagnosed or repaired. The manufacturer stated that the vehicle was not included in a recall and informed the contact to call NHTSA to file a complaint. The approximate failure mileage was 94,712.

NHTSA complaint #11015366
Aug 14, 2017unknown or other

I purchased this car 2 months ago. Today my wife when out with my 14 and 4 years old daughters and the car lost power and shut down while driving at around 60 MPH in the highway. Thankfully they are ok. But the car had to be towed. It starts but dies within seconds no idea what the problem is but I found that lots of people have had the same problem.

NHTSA complaint #11015263
Aug 1, 2017fuel/propulsion system

Drive train malfunction & check engine light came on. Scanned code came back as p0087 which translate to "low fuel rail pressure". Zeigler BMW of 11030 w 159th st, orland park, il 60467 states remedy is unavailable however they want to charge me $167.00 to diagnose it. Told me to wait for letter stating remedy is ready. $60k car I cant drive.

NHTSA complaint #11011930
Jul 26, 2017fuel/propulsion system

Gas smell in interior of vehicle, service noted that there is gas leak. There is a known recall but when we call BMW and they say they are prepared to do nothing at this time and we need to wait. We have been waiting for over 9 months now.

NHTSA complaint #11010870

2011 BMW 535I US recalls (0)

No safety recalls have been issued for the 2011 BMW 535I US.

Other BMW 535I US years

Frequently asked questions

Is the 2011 BMW 535I US a reliable car?

Our score for the 2011 BMW 535I US is 7.1/10 (average). It is based on 36 owner complaints and 0 recalls compared with other 2011 vehicles and other BMW 535I US years.

What are the most common problems with the 2011 BMW 535I US?

Owners most often report problems with tires (18 complaints), engine & cooling (7 complaints), wheels (4 complaints).

How many recalls does the 2011 BMW 535I US have?

There are no NHTSA safety recalls for this model year.

Source: NHTSA complaints & recalls, EPA fueleconomy.gov. Data updated November 18, 2026. Complaints are unverified reports by owners.