CarProblemsDB

Tesla Model Y problems by year

3,938 owner complaints across 8 model years. The 2023 model has the most complaints (1,201).

Best years

Years to avoid

Complaints by model year

2020285
20211,105
2022886
20231,201
2024340
2025117
20260
20274

All Tesla Model Y years

YearScoreComplaintsRecallsMPGSafety
2027 Tesla Model YNo data40131★★★★★
2026 Tesla Model YGood · 8.508129★★★★★
2025 Tesla Model YCaution · 3.71173121★★★★★
2024 Tesla Model YAvoid · 3.13405120★★★★★
2023 Tesla Model YAvoid · 11,20117123★★★★★
2022 Tesla Model YAvoid · 1.888620123★★★★★
2021 Tesla Model YAvoid · 1.51,10523125★★★★★
2020 Tesla Model YAvoid · 2.928524121★★★★★

Most common Tesla Model Y problems (all years)

Forward collision avoidance1,851 (47%)
Other / unknown574 (15%)
Speed control (cruise, throttle)556 (14%)
Brakes551 (14%)
Electrical system519 (13%)
Steering447 (11%)
Lane departure & lane assist347 (9%)
Suspension309 (8%)

Frequently asked questions

What is the worst year for the Tesla Model Y?

Based on NHTSA owner complaints, the 2023 Tesla Model Y scores lowest (1/10) with 1,201 complaints and 17 recalls.

What is the best year for the Tesla Model Y?

The 2026 Tesla Model Y scores highest (8.5/10) with 0 complaints.

What are the most common Tesla Model Y problems?

Across all years, owners most often report problems with: forward collision avoidance (1,851), other / unknown (574), speed control (cruise, throttle) (556).