CarProblemsDB

2005 Subaru Outback engine problems

26 owners reported engine & cooling problems — 10% of all 273 complaints about the 2005 Subaru Outback.

Engine & cooling complaints by Subaru Outback year

20256
20249
20231
202224
202123
202053
201940
201837
201744
201656
201550
201436
201368
201252
201193
201067
200918
200820
200718
200650
200526
200415
200319
200222
200122
200038

What owners report

Jan 30, 2021exterior lighting, structure, engine
This is the first Subaru I've ever owned and so far it's been a nightmare. I have had to repair: an oil leak in the engine that required the whole engine to be taken apart. While replacing a seemingly simple part, the hydraulic lifts that keep the back hatch open, the threading that holds the screw in broke off and I had to hire a mechanic yet again to weld that part to be… Read more

This is the first Subaru I've ever owned and so far it's been a nightmare. I have had to repair: an oil leak in the engine that required the whole engine to be taken apart. While replacing a seemingly simple part, the hydraulic lifts that keep the back hatch open, the threading that holds the screw in broke off and I had to hire a mechanic yet again to weld that part to be able to screw in the screw to hold the lift in place. And now, the entire interior lighting doesn't work, including the stereo, all the dome lights and the remote control system. In addition to that, the rear wiper doesn't work properly.

NHTSA complaint #11390746
Mar 21, 2019engine

Head gasket leak causing anti-freeze leaking.,. Began after 100k extended warranty expired. Told that caused due to defect in engine design. Later models with new design have not had problem. Subaru is knows about issue, but not taking any action to compensate for repair (ext. Cost around $3k).

NHTSA complaint #11190489
Mar 19, 2019engine, fuel/propulsion system
Traveling at highway speeds (~75 MPH) during the morning rush hour on the highway, experienced sudden loss of throttle control and resulting deceleration. The check engine light glowed steady and the cruise light was flashing. After pulling off to the shoulder (across three lanes) and shutting the engine off and restarting the engine, throttle control resumed. Check engine… Read more

Traveling at highway speeds (~75 MPH) during the morning rush hour on the highway, experienced sudden loss of throttle control and resulting deceleration. The check engine light glowed steady and the cruise light was flashing. After pulling off to the shoulder (across three lanes) and shutting the engine off and restarting the engine, throttle control resumed. Check engine light still glows steady and the cruise light is flashing with the cruise control not working.

NHTSA complaint #11189971
Feb 1, 2019engine
Bought car in 2013, have replaced the turbo 3 times! First within less than a month of ownership. Again in 2016 & again 3 months later. January 2018, again the car left me stranded for the 4th time! The Outback has been in the garage for almost 4 weeks, only to find out the turbo had a stripped support, which cost me a 'new, used motor!!! I bought my 1st Outback in 2000 off… Read more

Bought car in 2013, have replaced the turbo 3 times! First within less than a month of ownership. Again in 2016 & again 3 months later. January 2018, again the car left me stranded for the 4th time! The Outback has been in the garage for almost 4 weeks, only to find out the turbo had a stripped support, which cost me a 'new, used motor!!! I bought my 1st Outback in 2000 off the showroom floor, never had any major repairs, just routine maintenance. Drove her until sept 2013 due to a crash, which was totaled.

NHTSA complaint #11173599
Jun 23, 2016engine, fuel/propulsion system
Return fuel line leak. The leak is on the drivers side on top of the engine. A small rubber hose shrinks in the cold allowing fuel to leak on the engine block. A strong smell of fuel in the cabin when stationary. Leak goes away when the engine is warm. This problem has been reported in other Subaru models. I have repaired the problem once before as well as the previous owner… Read more

Return fuel line leak. The leak is on the drivers side on top of the engine. A small rubber hose shrinks in the cold allowing fuel to leak on the engine block. A strong smell of fuel in the cabin when stationary. Leak goes away when the engine is warm. This problem has been reported in other Subaru models. I have repaired the problem once before as well as the previous owner of the car, and now it needs to be repaired again.

NHTSA complaint #10876239
Aug 13, 2015engine
Tl* the contact owns a 2005 Subaru Outback. While driving at approximately 25 MPH, the accelerator pedal was applied and the vehicle experienced a loss of power as the check engine light blinked off and on. The vehicle was merged over to the side of the road and then driven to the contact's residence. The vehicle was taken to an independent mechanic, who was unable to diagnose… Read more

Tl* the contact owns a 2005 Subaru Outback. While driving at approximately 25 MPH, the accelerator pedal was applied and the vehicle experienced a loss of power as the check engine light blinked off and on. The vehicle was merged over to the side of the road and then driven to the contact's residence. The vehicle was taken to an independent mechanic, who was unable to diagnose the failure. The vehicle was not repaired. The approximate failure mileage was 150,000.

NHTSA complaint #10748434
Dec 4, 2013vehicle speed control, engine
Driving on interstate freeway, in heavy traffic, with the cruise control set, when the vehicle suddenly lost all power and throttle response. The "check engine" light came on, and the "cruise" light started blinking. Engine continued to run at high idle but speed and rpm were not maintained. I was lucky enough to cross 4 lanes of traffic and stop. Turned off the engine,… Read more

Driving on interstate freeway, in heavy traffic, with the cruise control set, when the vehicle suddenly lost all power and throttle response. The "check engine" light came on, and the "cruise" light started blinking. Engine continued to run at high idle but speed and rpm were not maintained. I was lucky enough to cross 4 lanes of traffic and stop. Turned off the engine, which was running at 2200 rpm. After a brief stop and investigation, I was able to restart the engine and drive normally to an auto parts store. I scanned the OBD ii code (dtc code) and found p2138 - throttle position sensor. No injuries, but this is a potentially deadly issue. Has recurred one time since. *tr

NHTSA complaint #10554798
May 7, 2013engine
Tl* the contact owns a 2005 Subaru Outback. The contact stated that while driving 60 MPH, he heard an abnormal noise as the vehicle failed to accelerate. The vehicle was towed to an independent mechanic for diagnosis and the contact was informed that the engine was blown. The failure had occurred two years prior to the recent failure and the engine had been replaced. The third… Read more

Tl* the contact owns a 2005 Subaru Outback. The contact stated that while driving 60 MPH, he heard an abnormal noise as the vehicle failed to accelerate. The vehicle was towed to an independent mechanic for diagnosis and the contact was informed that the engine was blown. The failure had occurred two years prior to the recent failure and the engine had been replaced. The third engine was installed and the vehicle was repaired. The failure and current mileage was 105,000. Returned by usps on 6/7/2013. 2nd attempt on 6/11/2013 failed. *kb

NHTSA complaint #10510935
Feb 27, 2013vehicle speed control, engine, fuel/propulsion system

On approximately 10 occasions right after a rain when I start up the car the engine light starts blinking and the car runs roughly with little power. After a short time the car power returns but the check engine light stays on for about a week. Once the light goes out the car then runs normal until the next rainstorm. It then does the same all over. *tr

NHTSA complaint #10500659
Feb 27, 2013engine
Subaru Outback 2.5xt. 2005 check engine light came on & I could hear whistling or whoosing sounds from engine area. Took it to an auto repair place slowly,asap & there it sits. Has 155,000 miles on it & I maintain & love my car! The gears in the turbo 'broke apart' & left shards of metal in oil pan & at this time who knows where else. Was hoping there was a recall as I… Read more

Subaru Outback 2.5xt. 2005 check engine light came on & I could hear whistling or whoosing sounds from engine area. Took it to an auto repair place slowly,asap & there it sits. Has 155,000 miles on it & I maintain & love my car! The gears in the turbo 'broke apart' & left shards of metal in oil pan & at this time who knows where else. Was hoping there was a recall as I maintain my vehicles & it seems like a manufacturer error. *tr

NHTSA complaint #10500621
Nov 14, 2011engine and engine cooling, electrical system, vehicle speed control
I have been having a problem with my car for the 2-years and has been getting worse. The throttle pedal at times will become non-responsive and the engine idle cannot be controlled. At this time the check engine light is on with a code. P2138. I have taken the car to the dealer with no luck they could not find anything wrong. The car has left me stranded several times and… Read more

I have been having a problem with my car for the 2-years and has been getting worse. The throttle pedal at times will become non-responsive and the engine idle cannot be controlled. At this time the check engine light is on with a code. P2138. I have taken the car to the dealer with no luck they could not find anything wrong. The car has left me stranded several times and I had to limp or be towed home. The rpm can be anywhere from idle to 3000 rpm and as I said the pedal has no control. I have replaced the accelerator pedal assembly and the problem was gone for the past six months. It has now failed again. *tr

NHTSA complaint #10435609
Oct 30, 2011engine and engine cooling, electrical system
Second time this has happened. When in a stopped position and intend to pull out, motor running, but gas pedal does not engage. Push all the way to floor - still nothing. In order to correct, must turn off engine and disconnect battery cable so vehicle can reset itself. Also had problem when sitting still where vehicle began idling as if accelerator being pressed down -… Read more

Second time this has happened. When in a stopped position and intend to pull out, motor running, but gas pedal does not engage. Push all the way to floor - still nothing. In order to correct, must turn off engine and disconnect battery cable so vehicle can reset itself. Also had problem when sitting still where vehicle began idling as if accelerator being pressed down - lasted 5-10 seconds then backed off. When purchased car used, had problems with cruise control not working and light flashing continuously. Found that injector had to be replaced - apparently tied to cruise mechanism. This corrected the problem but quite expensive to repair. *tr

NHTSA complaint #10433565
Jun 19, 2011engine and engine cooling

2005 Outback x limited with 67,000 miles. Check engine light comes on followed by a whining sound from engine compartment and then rattling noises accompanied by loss of power. Car was transported to garage and diagnosed with blown turbo. Metal shavings discovered in oil filter. Total engine loss. Subaru denies coverage and will not accept responsibility for design flaw. *tr

NHTSA complaint #10407420
May 20, 2011engine and engine cooling
Tl*the contact owns a 2005 Subaru Outback. The contact stated while driving on an incline the vehicle responded slowly. The cruise control and check engine light illuminated on the instrument panel. The dealership diagnosis determined that the turbo charger filter was clogged and the shaft in the turbo charger was broken. The vehicle was not repaired. The manufacturer was… Read more

Tl*the contact owns a 2005 Subaru Outback. The contact stated while driving on an incline the vehicle responded slowly. The cruise control and check engine light illuminated on the instrument panel. The dealership diagnosis determined that the turbo charger filter was clogged and the shaft in the turbo charger was broken. The vehicle was not repaired. The manufacturer was contacted. The failure and current mileage was 67,446.

NHTSA complaint #10402198
May 17, 2011engine and engine cooling
Subaru Outback 2005 pzev - head gasket failure. The cylinder head gaskets on this vehicle have failed such that engine oil drips onto the hot exhaust system, and produces visible, foul smelling smoke whenever the car is driven. Manufacturer has refused to repair under warranty, or recognize a problem, in spite of similar failures in earlier models, and previous class… Read more

Subaru Outback 2005 pzev - head gasket failure. The cylinder head gaskets on this vehicle have failed such that engine oil drips onto the hot exhaust system, and produces visible, foul smelling smoke whenever the car is driven. Manufacturer has refused to repair under warranty, or recognize a problem, in spite of similar failures in earlier models, and previous class action lawsuit settlement because of those failures. The car is still under an emissions warranty that will expire at 157,500 miles. The car was sold as a partial zero-emissions vehicle, but clearly the smoke from the dripping oil exceeds any emission standard. My feeling is that the manufacturer should repair the car under the emissions warranty, as well as prior failure history. *tr

NHTSA complaint #10401241
May 9, 2011engine and engine cooling
At approximately 85,000 miles, the check engine light on our 2005 Subaru Outback xt went on and we took the vehicle in to our local repair shop to check the light and they recommended having the vehicle towed to our Subaru dealer. The vehicle was towed in and the dealer service person called stating that timthe turbo had failed (along with the cv boot & alternator belt). I… Read more

At approximately 85,000 miles, the check engine light on our 2005 Subaru Outback xt went on and we took the vehicle in to our local repair shop to check the light and they recommended having the vehicle towed to our Subaru dealer. The vehicle was towed in and the dealer service person called stating that timthe turbo had failed (along with the cv boot & alternator belt). I provided the information regarding our official Subaru 100,000 mile gold plus "extended service contract" which we purchased for $1975. The service representative would not confirm whether or not these components would be covered under our service contract and then called me and said Subaru denied the claim pending receipt of service records. My husband and my father have changed the oil, air filters and performed general service in combination with service by various service shops. My records are not complete and I expect that Subaru will try to deny coverage of the turbo due to this. There are ample reports on Subaru forums reporting the same failure and I feel that this problem is not due to owner negligence, but by faulty design. This type of failure should be the responsibility of the manufacturer and they should service the vehicle per the service contract without causing undue stress to the owner of the vehicle. *tr

NHTSA complaint #10399717
Apr 25, 2011engine and engine cooling
Tl* the contact owns a 2005 Subaru Outback. The contact stated that the engine failed. The contact took the vehicle to the dealer and they were told that the banjo filters screen failed and sent shards of metal through the engine. The dealer told the contact that in 2007, the vehicle was serviced because of the failure and the engine was previously rebuilt. The contact stated… Read more

Tl* the contact owns a 2005 Subaru Outback. The contact stated that the engine failed. The contact took the vehicle to the dealer and they were told that the banjo filters screen failed and sent shards of metal through the engine. The dealer told the contact that in 2007, the vehicle was serviced because of the failure and the engine was previously rebuilt. The contact stated that the information was not listed on the vehicle history report. The vehicle was not repaired. The failure mileage and current mileage was 62,000.

NHTSA complaint #10397299
Oct 16, 2006engine and engine cooling, exterior lightingFire

2005 Subaru Outback 2.5xt was parked in a public / private parking structure at approximately 6:30pm on 10/13/2005. At approximately 8pm the fire alarm was triggered by vehicle catching on fire. Fire dept found no signs of arson or foul play, looked to be an electrical fire in the front right headlight cluster. No response from Subaru, insurance dropped my policy - loss not covered! *nm

NHTSA complaint #10170888
Feb 26, 2006engine and engine coolingFire

2005 Subaru Outback totally destroyed by fire of unknown origin approximately 30 minutes after engine shut off. No one was in the car and police/fire dept determined arson unlikely. *nm

NHTSA complaint #10151244
← All 2005 Subaru Outback problems & recalls