CarProblemsDB

Mini Cooper S problems by year

1,659 owner complaints across 21 model years. The 2005 model has the most complaints (314).

Best years

Years to avoid

Complaints by model year

200283
2003217
2004247
2005314
2006186
2007249
2008168
20090
201059
201131
201223
201323
201413
201518
20169
20174
20194
20205
20221
20241
20254

All Mini Cooper S years

YearScoreComplaintsRecallsMPGSafety
2025 Mini Cooper SGood · 7.64330—
2024 Mini Cooper SNo data1029—
2022 Mini Cooper SNo data1028—
2020 Mini Cooper SAverage · 6.25229—
2019 Mini Cooper SNo data4127—
2017 Mini Cooper SAverage · 6.54327—
2016 Mini Cooper SAverage · 69327—
2015 Mini Cooper SAverage · 618429—
2014 Mini Cooper SAverage · 6.513429—
2013 Mini Cooper SAverage · 6.723129—
2012 Mini Cooper SAverage · 6.523229—
2011 Mini Cooper SCaution · 5.231329—
2010 Mini Cooper SCaution · 3.859428—
2009 Mini Cooper SGood · 9.40328—
2008 Mini Cooper SAvoid · 2.6168426—
2007 Mini Cooper SAvoid · 2.3249425—
2006 Mini Cooper SAvoid · 3.1186124—
2005 Mini Cooper SAvoid · 2.7314224—
2004 Mini Cooper SAvoid · 2.9247225—
2003 Mini Cooper SAvoid · 2.2217225—
2002 Mini Cooper SCaution · 3.6831——

Most common Mini Cooper S problems (all years)

Steering668 (40%)
Engine & cooling443 (27%)
Airbags243 (15%)
Electrical system158 (10%)
Transmission & powertrain98 (6%)
Visibility, windows & wipers70 (4%)
Fuel & propulsion system49 (3%)
Other / unknown48 (3%)

Frequently asked questions

What is the worst year for the Mini Cooper S?

Based on NHTSA owner complaints, the 2003 Mini Cooper S scores lowest (2.2/10) with 217 complaints and 2 recalls.

What is the best year for the Mini Cooper S?

The 2009 Mini Cooper S scores highest (9.4/10) with 0 complaints.

What are the most common Mini Cooper S problems?

Across all years, owners most often report problems with: steering (668), engine & cooling (443), airbags (243).