CarProblemsDB

2005 GMC Sierra 2500 HD engine problems

14 owners reported engine & cooling problems — 17% of all 82 complaints about the 2005 GMC Sierra 2500 HD.

Engine & cooling complaints by GMC Sierra 2500 HD year

200514
20049
20038
200213
200120

What owners report

Sep 1, 2017electrical system, unknown or other, engine

Always turns off while driving or while at idle

NHTSA complaint #11021058
Aug 20, 2013engine

2005 GMC 2500hd with 6.0 liter gas motor. Left and right bank exhaust manifold to engine bolts broken off in head. Leaking exhaust fumes and causing my check engine light to come on. GM need to have a recall on this due to the number of vehicles out there with this problem. This is also an emission problem due to it will cause the cat converter to overheat.. Epa? Thank you *tr

NHTSA complaint #10536241
Oct 24, 2012power train, engine
Exhaust manifold bolts are breaking off for no apparent reason. I have four broken already and an exhaust leak developing. This appears to be a defect in manufacturing. I have a friend with two of the same trucks that the same thing has happened to. There are numerous complaints posted on the web. I have had many vehicles over the years and worked them hard but have never seen… Read more

Exhaust manifold bolts are breaking off for no apparent reason. I have four broken already and an exhaust leak developing. This appears to be a defect in manufacturing. I have a friend with two of the same trucks that the same thing has happened to. There are numerous complaints posted on the web. I have had many vehicles over the years and worked them hard but have never seen a broken exhaust manifold bolt on any of them. This can be a dangerous situation as having exhaust leaks under hood could cause a fire. As far as I know GM has not issued a bulletin or recall on this but there should be some remediation as this is an expensive repair and it is not a failure caused by the lack of maintenance. I have also heard reports of repaired units breaking again in about the same number of miles and having to be repaired again. *tr

NHTSA complaint #10482144
Sep 4, 2012service brakes, hydraulic, engine and engine cooling
Tl* the contact owns a 2005 GMC sierra 3500. The contact stated that while driving 40 MPH, the brakes were engaged and the vehicle failed to stop. The contact mentioned that he had to engage the emergency brake in order for the vehicle to stop. Also, the contact stated that after inspecting the vehicle he noticed oil leaking. The vehicle was not taken to the dealer. The… Read more

Tl* the contact owns a 2005 GMC sierra 3500. The contact stated that while driving 40 MPH, the brakes were engaged and the vehicle failed to stop. The contact mentioned that he had to engage the emergency brake in order for the vehicle to stop. Also, the contact stated that after inspecting the vehicle he noticed oil leaking. The vehicle was not taken to the dealer. The vehicle was taken to an independent mechanic who diagnosed that the brake lines needed to be replaced. The manufacturer was made aware of the failure who did not offer any assistance. The failure and current mileage was 42,000. Updated 10/24/12 *cn updated 11/08/12

NHTSA complaint #10473726
Jan 16, 2012engine and engine cooling
Broken exhaust manifold bolts. Front and rear manifold bolts have broken on both the passenger and driver sides. As a result exhaust manifolds are now warping putting undue stress on remaining manifold bolts and creating an exhaust leak. Bolts are steel, manifolds are cast, and heads are aluminum. Dissimilar metals, heat, and moisture have caused the bolts to prematurely rust… Read more

Broken exhaust manifold bolts. Front and rear manifold bolts have broken on both the passenger and driver sides. As a result exhaust manifolds are now warping putting undue stress on remaining manifold bolts and creating an exhaust leak. Bolts are steel, manifolds are cast, and heads are aluminum. Dissimilar metals, heat, and moisture have caused the bolts to prematurely rust and fail. Emissions dilution will not allow for a passing smog test in 2013. GMC refuses to address the issue at hand, even though this is a recurring issue on all v8 engines. Estimate to repair; $2500. *tr

NHTSA complaint #10443993
Aug 31, 2011engine and engine cooling

This model year has an engine defect from the manufacturer. The head gasket is known to break causing the engine to overheat. This can cause several safety issues dependent on the circumstance at the time of the engine overheating. After some research, it is openly known that this is a defect from the manufacturer for this particular engine year.

NHTSA complaint #10423588
Aug 1, 2011suspension, service brakes, hydraulic, parking brake, engine and engine cooling, structure
Major rust of the undercarriage of my 2005 GMC sierra 78,000 miles. So far had to replace brake rotors, brake lines , fuel radiator and lines. Frame and cross members as well as control arms are all rusted. Made complaint with GMC they had me bring to a dealer to tell me this is normal rusting. Two of my relatives have the same year truck but are not experiencing this issue… Read more

Major rust of the undercarriage of my 2005 GMC sierra 78,000 miles. So far had to replace brake rotors, brake lines , fuel radiator and lines. Frame and cross members as well as control arms are all rusted. Made complaint with GMC they had me bring to a dealer to tell me this is normal rusting. Two of my relatives have the same year truck but are not experiencing this issue and we all live in the same area drive same roads. *kb

NHTSA complaint #10416571
Jun 19, 2011engine and engine cooling

This is my 2nd GMC 6.0l that has broken exhaust bolts first truck broke 3 bolts at 32,000 miles, replaced by dealer and broke bolts off again at 39,000 miles. Now have 2005 with 51,000 mile with three broken manifold bolts and an exhaust leak. This is a very expensive repair that is a design problem. *tr

NHTSA complaint #10407412
Dec 5, 2010engine and engine cooling

Exhaust manifold bolts broken off (4). 6.0 l engine and exhaust is escaping and entering cabin. *tr

NHTSA complaint #10369228
Oct 30, 2010engine and engine cooling

Exhaust leaking under hood due to broken exhaust manifold bolts. Carbon monoxide hazard. This seems to be a common problem for owners of several years of GM engines. *tr

NHTSA complaint #10363033
May 9, 2010engine and engine cooling
The exhaust manifold bolts were broke on side of the exhaust manifold so far. The mechanic at fw tucker and son, in, oswego, ny 315-342-0444 stated that they have replaced these on 12 trucks and after further research, I have found that there have been over 12,000 vehicles that have to had these replaced. The truck is less than 5 years old and has 54,000 miles on it. I… Read more

The exhaust manifold bolts were broke on side of the exhaust manifold so far. The mechanic at fw tucker and son, in, oswego, ny 315-342-0444 stated that they have replaced these on 12 trucks and after further research, I have found that there have been over 12,000 vehicles that have to had these replaced. The truck is less than 5 years old and has 54,000 miles on it. I called and filed a complaint with GMC (service request #[xxx] ) and was told that they found that it wasn't a common problem and they found no indication that it was an ongoing problem, however 12,000 vehicles is an ongoing problem. The vehicle is a 2005 GMC sierra 2500hd truck. I had to pay to have the exhaust manifold removed, to have the bolts extracted, the cost of the new bolts and the installation of the bolts, new exhaust manifold gaskets and seals. I also had to pay to have the engine oil removed and the replacement of the engine oil dipstick tube. Information redacted pursuant to the freedom of information act (foia), 5 u.s.c. 552(b)(6). *tr

NHTSA complaint #10329482
Feb 8, 2009engine and engine cooling

Ticking noise coming from engine compartment. *tr

NHTSA complaint #10257978
Apr 25, 2008engine and engine cooling, power train
Tl*the contact owns a 2005 GMC Sierra 2500 HD. The contact stated that when he drives his vehicle uphill with a trailer in tow, the vehicle slams into third gear, jerks, and overheats. The failure occurs at various speeds. The failure mileage was 35,000. Updated 5/13/08 *cn the consumer stated several dealers were telling him different things as to what was wrong with… Read more

Tl*the contact owns a 2005 GMC Sierra 2500 HD. The contact stated that when he drives his vehicle uphill with a trailer in tow, the vehicle slams into third gear, jerks, and overheats. The failure occurs at various speeds. The failure mileage was 35,000. Updated 5/13/08 *cn the consumer stated several dealers were telling him different things as to what was wrong with the vehicle. The consumer believed there is a problem with the engine, transmission and transfer case. One dealer told the consumer the wrong transfer case was in the vehicle. A new serpentine belt was installed, the front differential was replaced, because the axle shaft was stuck, the axle seal was leaking and both high pressure lines of the hydroboost were leaking as well. The engine light illuminated. The charge air cooler was leaking residual oil from the lower right corner. Updated 05/13/08.

NHTSA complaint #10225718
Apr 9, 2007engine and engine cooling
When climbing a significant grade , 6%, while towing 12.500# 5th wheel on a day with high ambient temperature , 95% engine temperature, immediately began to climb and reached almost overheat when I fortunately found a place to pull off the road. Incident took place on the grapevine in ca. If I hadn't been able to pull over I would have been stuck in traffic lane with 18… Read more

When climbing a significant grade , 6%, while towing 12.500# 5th wheel on a day with high ambient temperature , 95% engine temperature, immediately began to climb and reached almost overheat when I fortunately found a place to pull off the road. Incident took place on the grapevine in ca. If I hadn't been able to pull over I would have been stuck in traffic lane with 18 wheelers right behind me. 2 dealers were unable to help.*ak

NHTSA complaint #10187387
← All 2005 GMC Sierra 2500 HD problems & recalls