CarProblemsDB

BMW M5 problems by year

104 owner complaints across 20 model years. The 2006 model has the most complaints (39).

Best years

Years to avoid

Complaints by model year

20004
20014
20026
20033
200639
20076
20086
20090
20101
201310
20142
20153
20161
20184
20198
20202
20213
20221
20251
20260

All BMW M5 years

YearScoreComplaintsRecallsMPGSafety
2026 BMW M5No data0114—
2025 BMW M5Good · 8.91214—
2022 BMW M5No data1017—
2021 BMW M5No data3117—
2020 BMW M5Good · 8.22317—
2019 BMW M5Average · 6.48317—
2018 BMW M5Good · 7.94317—
2016 BMW M5Good · 9.31217—
2015 BMW M5No data3117—
2014 BMW M5No data2117—
2013 BMW M5Caution · 5.410217—
2010 BMW M5Good · 9.31213—
2009 BMW M5Good · 9.60213—
2008 BMW M5Average · 6.36213—
2007 BMW M5Good · 8.16113—
2006 BMW M5Caution · 4.739113—
2003 BMW M5No data3115—
2002 BMW M5Average · 6.16215—
2001 BMW M5Good · 8.24315—
2000 BMW M5Average · 6.94215—

Most common BMW M5 problems (all years)

Airbags43 (41%)
Engine & cooling27 (26%)
Transmission & powertrain13 (13%)
Electrical system11 (11%)
Seat belts10 (10%)
Seats6 (6%)
Other / unknown6 (6%)
Fuel & propulsion system6 (6%)

Frequently asked questions

What is the worst year for the BMW M5?

Based on NHTSA owner complaints, the 2006 BMW M5 scores lowest (4.7/10) with 39 complaints and 1 recall.

What is the best year for the BMW M5?

The 2009 BMW M5 scores highest (9.6/10) with 0 complaints.

What are the most common BMW M5 problems?

Across all years, owners most often report problems with: airbags (43), engine & cooling (27), transmission & powertrain (13).